On a scale from 1-10, where do you rate Cotto's win over Foreman?

[SOY-COMO-SOY]

gave him a 4, foreman isnt a puncher and only asset is his footwork which was stopped due to his slipping 3x and 2x on his bad knee.

want to see cotto go against a tougher 154lber, kermit or angulo would be good then he needs to go against the elite (pwilliams, martinez, marg)

[-DSG-]

nine you know

[Pugilistic™]

I give it a 7, possibly a 8.

Foreman was nothing special but is still a top 10 154 pounder and was a champ.

Another good thing to point out was Cotto was coming off a tough loss and he was fighting at a higher weight for the first time.

[Boss2k10]

Cotto beat a featherfisted part time boxer full time rabbi paper champion.

Obviously its a poor win.

[piano man]

8,5

it was his first fight at 154 he did freakin great

[piano man]

Cotto beat a featherfisted part time boxer full time rabbi paper champion.

Obviously its a poor win.

you

dont

know

****

about

boxing

[BMWM3P]

I give it a seven he looked very good and it' was a good sign of things to come with. Manny in his corner things will only get better.

[Devils Advocate]

8. once again, he outboxed a boxer

I gave him a 10 just b/c he was suppose to be shot right!! He moved up and fought quite impressive. He also didn't get cut or suffer any real damage unlike his last 2 fights so I think he deserved the 10 b/c he had everything to lose and Foreman had everything to gain!!