Better resume: Cotto or Williams?

[AKATheMack]

Williams can beat every name on Cotto's resume, can Cotto do the same with Williams resume?

Common opponents Margarito and Quintana. They both lost to the one the other beat.

[Mr. Fantastic]

They are about even........

Do you give Williams props for the Winky fight??

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Do you give Williams props for the Winky fight??

It was an okay win that many didnt expect him to win. It wasnt an epic victory. Good win though.

[borikua]

Cotto but not by much.

[Mr. Fantastic]

It was an okay win that many didnt expect him to win. It wasnt an epic victory. Good win though.

But yet you don't give Oscar any credit for Whitaker and Chavez. LOL I told you that you are a double standard fan. I don't care how much I hate Hopkins, I still think he's an ATG. I don't let hate cloud me like a whole bunch of you so called fans.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

But yet you don't give Oscar any credit for Whitaker and Chavez. LOL I told you that you are a double standard fan. I don't care how much I hate Hopkins, I still think he's an ATG. I don't let hate cloud me like a whole bunch of you so called fans.

Oscar is a hall of famer. Nothing more.

[BostonGuy]

They are about even........

...................Seriously...
________
FREE ****

[dans]

Wins For Williams:
Margarito
Martinez
Wright
Quintana
Cintron
Mitchell
Matthysse

Wins For Cotto:
Mosley
Clottey
Judah
Quintana
Malignaggi
Corley
Torres

It's Cotto, mainly because Williams' resume is decieving.

I thought he lost to both Sergio and Cintron. Williams could just as easily be 0-2 in his last 2.

[ADozenArrows]

is this a serious question??

Why wouldn't it be serious?

I think the resumes are comparable. Cotto's career has been a bit more consistant but, that's not to take away from Williams who has had trouble making fights at 147 and 154 so he's had to jump around. They're both warriors.

I'd love to see Cotto-Williams at 154 if Cotto gets past Foreman.

[borikua]

Plus Torres, Quintana, and Malignaggi were undefeated.