Would Joe Calzaghe be rated more if he was American

[Evil Abed]

Not sure.

But I'm pretty sure he would have a couple of L's on his record though.

How that would have effected his ranking I don't know.

[Terrel]

I dont think he woud have been as popular. The Americans would have forced him to fight real talent earlier in his career, possibly resulting in losses. Calzaghe against a younger, dominant Bernard would have been awhole different result.