Floyd HAS NEVER BEATEN a BONA FIDE GREAT FIGHTER in their PRIME

[Bhopreign]

you asked name me a great fighter kostya beat. i gave you the answer. i never said he was prime. how much credit does floyd get for beating a 39 year old 1 year & 5 month inactive shane? or a old shot semi retired oscar?

i ve already explained that you dont have to beat ATGs left & right to be in the hall of fame. this thread isnt about that. this thread is about floyd not having beaten a bona fide ATG in their prime.

you asked which ones, ive already answered. here's one sure name:

PACQUIAO.

Well when the day comes where Pac is found out about the PED's lets see if your opinion changes. You give Floyd no credit for Oscar and Shane yet give Tsyzu supreme credit for beating Chavez, yet Shane and Chavez were both the same age when they fought Tsyzu and Floyd respectedly. Bias much?

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

Well when the day comes where Pac is found out about the PED's lets see if your opinion changes. You give Floyd no credit for Oscar and Shane yet give Tsyzu supreme credit for beating Chavez, yet Shane and Chavez were both the same age when they fought Tsyzu and Floyd respectedly. Bias much?

you are mentally twisted. when did i give supreme credit to kostya for beating chavez?

you asked name me a great fighter kostya beat. i gave you one. you didnt say name me a great prime fighter kostya beat. did you not read the thread title? did i create a kostya beat a great prime fighter in chavez thread?

please point out in any of my post denying floyd is a great hall of fame fighter. i dare you. go check my history.

again,

did you not read the opening post:

Its true.


Now im not saying floyd is NOT a great fighter, he is but the level of greatness he & his delusional fan base claim IS WAYYYY OFF BASE.

Just look at his resume & ask yourself this question, name me a a fighter you could rightly classify as a GREAT Hall of Fame fighter that floyd beat in his prime?

He doesnt have none.


The 5 best names on Floyd's resume are

1. Shane Mosley - bona fide great fighter. HOF.
2. Juan Manuel Marquez - bona fide great fighter. HOF.
3. Oscar De La HOya - bona fide great fighter. HOF.
4. Diego Corrales - very good fighter. Not a true HOF great fighter.
5. Jose Luis Castillo - very good fighter. Not a true HOF great fighter.

The 3 true great HOF fighters floyd fought were all past prime & one was severely taken advantage of in abomination of a fight.


Floyd doesnt even have a ATG fighter in his resume yet he & his delusional fan base claim G.O.A.T?

After those 5 best names, the next five are

6. Hatton
7. Arturo Gatti
8. Genaro Hernandez
9. Zab Judah
10. Carlos Baldomir


His resume is really thin when you start trying to compare it to other ATG fighters.

None of those fighters i listed above are true bona fide great HALL OF FAME fighters.


Floyd is a great fighter, HOF, with ZERO A+ wins vs ATG fighters. I dont deny floyd's greatness, just the level of greatness he & his delusional fan boy fluffers thinks they deserve.

again, reading & mental comprehension is coming into play here.

[Bhopreign]

you are mentally twisted. when did i give supreme credit to kostya for beating chavez?

you asked name me a great fighter kostya beat. i gave you one. you didnt say name me a great prime fighter kostya beat. did you not read the thread title? did i create a kostya beat a great prime fighter in chavez thread?

please point out in any of my post denying floyd is a great hall of fame fighter. i dare you. go check my history.

again,

did you not read the opening post:




again, reading & mental comprehension is coming into play here.

Your attacks do nothing to nullify the consistent discrepancies in your posts. Floyd has beaten great fighters, Shane is a great fighter as well as Oscar. If you call Tsyzu a great fighter yet you cant name a great fighter he's beaten then how is he great?

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

Your attacks do nothing to nullify the consistent discrepancies in your posts. Floyd has beaten great fighters, Shane is a great fighter as well as Oscar. If you call Tsyzu a great fighter yet you cant name a great fighter he's beaten then how is he great?

..................................

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

here you go freedom....

[Doctor_Tenma]

here you go freedom....

I prefer Freedom's thread, atleast he's asking for "elite". You on the other hand is asking for great fighters. You do know that great fighters are hard to come by, right? To answer your question Floyd hasn't beaten a great fighter, no shame in that either, I'm dead serious too. If your trying to make him look bad because of that then

[Kagami Taiga]

I prefer Freedom's thread, atleast he's asking for "elite". You on the other hand is asking for great fighters. You do know that great fighters are hard to come by, right? To answer your question Floyd hasn't beaten a great fighter, no shame in that either, I'm dead serious too. If your trying to make him look bad because of that then

this is true...the only truly great fighter that floyd actually has/had the chance to fight in their prime is pac. it remains to be seen if that fight happens. but cotto/margarito arent great fighters...floyd has wins against fighters of their level.

[Abraham Reyes]

Its true.


Now im not saying floyd is NOT a great fighter, he is but the level of greatness he & his delusional fan base claim IS WAYYYY OFF BASE.

Just look at his resume & ask yourself this question, name me a a fighter you could rightly classify as a GREAT Hall of Fame fighter that floyd beat in his prime?

He doesnt have none.


The 5 best names on Floyd's resume are

1. Shane Mosley - bona fide great fighter. HOF.
2. Juan Manuel Marquez - bona fide great fighter. HOF.
3. Oscar De La HOya - bona fide great fighter. HOF.
4. Diego Corrales - very good fighter. Not a true HOF great fighter.
5. Jose Luis Castillo - very good fighter. Not a true HOF great fighter.

The 3 true great HOF fighters floyd fought were all past prime & one was severely taken advantage of in abomination of a fight.


Floyd doesnt even have a ATG fighter in his resume yet he & his delusional fan base claim G.O.A.T?

After those 5 best names, the next five are

6. Hatton
7. Arturo Gatti
8. Genaro Hernandez
9. Zab Judah
10. Carlos Baldomir


His resume is really thin when you start trying to compare it to other ATG fighters.

None of those fighters i listed above are true bona fide great HALL OF FAME fighters.


Floyd is a great fighter, HOF, with ZERO A+ wins vs ATG fighters. I dont deny floyd's greatness, just the level of greatness he & his delusional fan boy fluffers thinks they deserve.

so are you saying that arturo gatti is not an ATG and a HOF? if so then F UCK YOU *******!!!

[Doctor_Tenma]

This is so you can understand the rarity of beating a great fighter. Just to name a few...

B-Hop - Tito Trinidad
Pernell Whitaker - JCC, Azumah Nelson
Pacquiao - MAB
Aaron Pryor - Arguello

I could name Duran, Leonard, Ali, SRR, but no point in that because they're in the Top 10 all time for good reason, those guys have beaten many great fighters. Nonetheless it's still rare.

[Walt Liquor]

agreed with dom and dempsey.

floyd hasn't beaten a prime great fighter at their weight. doesn't mean his resume sucks.

and yes, obviously floyd is nowhere near goat.


i still will never get why he doesn't just man up and fight manny. (and vice Versa). Manny already has 2 wins over prime or VERY close to prime fighters though.