Floyd HAS NEVER BEATEN a BONA FIDE GREAT FIGHTER in their PRIME

[Phenom]

JLC is a HOF and chico(rip) was a great fighter and a borderline HOFer Floyd fought and beat both of them in their absolute prime


not too many ATG fighters are around the same division and at their prime at the same time that rarely happens

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

Or because you never said it. In summary, you say Floyd never fought a great fighter in his prime yet the ones he didnt fight were not great, go figure.

pacquiao, kostya tsyzu, younger oscar, younger shane, to a lesser extent joel casamayor. he chose a face first brawler in castillo instead of a crafty, slick, casamayor. he also didnt fight stevie johnston.

even the fighters that he should have fought that are not hall of famers, namely cotto & margarito are greater fighters than baldomir or judah.

for all the crap floyd fans give pac for not fighting slick black fighters, they seem to excuse floyd for doing so too.

stay in school.

[Bhopreign]

stay in school.

I replied to that in what year should Floyd have fought them, no reply. Again I asked if Tszyu was a great fighter, still no reply.

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

JLC is a HOF and chico(rip) was a great fighter and a borderline HOFer Floyd fought and beat both of them in their absolute prime

lmfaoooo. i made a poll about this in the history section. the answer was an overwhelming NO by all the great historians of this site.

didnt need to make that thread. already knew he wasnt. just wanted back up.

i bet control of my account that jose luis castillo doesnt get in IBHOF OR WBHOF.


sig it.

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

I replied to that in what year should Floyd have fought them, no reply. Again I asked if Tszyu was a great fighter, still no reply.

he's a great fighter who should be in the hall of fame. not a ATG, but a hall of famer. i also answered this.

stop watching B.E.T

[Bhopreign]

he's a great fighter who should be in the hall of fame. not a ATG, but a hall of famer. i also answered this.

stop watching B.E.T

And why should Tszyu be in the Hall of Fame, what great fighter/fighters did he beat? Youre bodying yourself by the second.

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

And why should Tszyu be in the Hall of Fame, what great fighter/fighters did he beat? Youre bodying yourself by the second.

this isnt about kostya tszyzu. you dont have to beat ATG fighters to be in the hall of fame. the thread title is floyd has never beaten a bona fide great fighter i his prime, not kostya.

as for your question, kostya beat the greatest mexican fighter of all time. ill let you figure that one out.


now go do your homework riley.

[JDezi4]

Yet people complain that he didn't fight Cotto, Margarito, and Williams, which, based off of ur assessment, wouldn't have meant much anyway.

No, not the GOAT. Probably not even top 10 ATG. But he still beats Pac...

Pac is also over-rated, do one on him too...

Hell, so was Joe Calzaghe... U should just go down the list and expose all these over-rated bums

[Bhopreign]

this isnt about kostya tszyzu. you dont have to beat ATG fighters to be in the hall of fame. the thread title is floyd has never beaten a bona fide great fighter i his prime, not kostya.

as for your question, kostya beat the greatest mexican fighter of all time. ill let you figure that one out.


now go do your homework riley.

You keep bodying yourself. So how much credit should Tsyzu get for beating Chavez?

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

You keep bodying yourself. So how much credit should Tsyzu get for beating Chavez?

you asked name me a great fighter kostya beat. i gave you the answer. i never said he was prime. how much credit does floyd get for beating a 39 year old 1 year & 5 month inactive shane? or a old shot semi retired oscar?

i ve already explained that you dont have to beat ATGs left & right to be in the hall of fame. this thread isnt about that. this thread is about floyd not having beaten a bona fide ATG in their prime.

you asked which ones, ive already answered. here's one sure name:

PACQUIAO.