Floyd HAS NEVER BEATEN a BONA FIDE GREAT FIGHTER in their PRIME

[LoadedWraps]

Its true.


Now im not saying floyd is NOT a great fighter, he is but the level of greatness he & his delusional fan base claim IS WAYYYY OFF BASE.

Just look at his resume & ask yourself this question, name me a a fighter you could rightly classify as a GREAT Hall of Fame fighter that floyd beat in his prime?

He doesnt have none.


The 5 best names on Floyd's resume are

1. Shane Mosley - bona fide great fighter. HOF.
2. Juan Manuel Marquez - bona fide great fighter. HOF.
3. Oscar De La HOya - bona fide great fighter. HOF.
4. Diego Corrales - very good fighter. Not a true HOF great fighter.
5. Jose Luis Castillo - very good fighter. Not a true HOF great fighter.

The 3 true great HOF fighters floyd fought were all past prime & one was severely taken advantage of in abomination of a fight.


Floyd doesnt even have a ATG fighter in his resume yet he & his delusional fan base claim G.O.A.T?

After those 5 best names, the next five are

6. Hatton
7. Arturo Gatti
8. Genaro Hernandez
9. Zab Judah
10. Carlos Baldomir


His resume is really thin when you start trying to compare it to other ATG fighters.

None of those fighters i listed above are true bona fide great HALL OF FAME fighters.


Floyd is a great fighter, HOF, with ZERO A+ wins vs ATG fighters. I dont deny floyd's greatness, just the level of greatness he & his delusional fan boy fluffers thinks they deserve.

Floyd is a great fighter a top 50 ATG, but no one sane would call him GOAT.

[mezoomozaa]

Pacquiao has a better resume than Mayweather, Mayweather isn't even the greatest of his era, may be he is top 50 or 100 ATGs

[TonitosWay]

Floyd is a great fighter a top 50 ATG, but no one sane would call him GOAT.

Exactly.

Pac has the more impressive resume & wins thanks to stronger names, style & riskier opposition but I still say Floyd Mayweather will be known as the biggest fighter of our generation.

[The Raw Dog]

All I take from this thread is that once Floyd beats Pacquiao, he can never get credit for doing it because Manny's fans will then claim Manny wasn't in his prime.

Why should Mayweather even fight him at this point?

[miron_lang]

Exactly.

Pac has the more impressive resume & wins thanks to stronger names, style & riskier opposition but I still say Floyd Mayweather will be known as the biggest fighter of our generation.

What?

[miron_lang]

Exactly.

Pac has the more impressive resume & wins thanks to stronger names, style & riskier opposition but I still say Floyd Mayweather will be known as the biggest fighter of our generation.

All I take from this thread is that once Floyd beats Pacquiao, he can never get credit for doing it because Manny's fans will then claim Manny wasn't in his prime.

Why should Mayweather even fight him at this point?

unbelievable

[QballLobo]

All I take from this thread is that once Floyd beats Pacquiao, he can never get credit for doing it because Manny's fans will then claim Manny wasn't in his prime.

Why should Mayweather even fight him at this point?

And he has no one to blame but himself for that. You had the #1 and #2 P4P in their physical prime in 2009 and 2010. I realize Manny balked at the test but there was a deal to be made there. Floyd would have been a favorite in that fight and once he won no one could tell him **** about not taking challanges or ducking after that. A guy that calls himself money turned down would could have been hundreds of millions of dollars (if there were re matches) because of a few testing dates that could have been worked out if cooler heads prevailed.
Now if they fight Floyd should get crap for it because its 4-5 years too late. Floyd is the A side and he decides if the fight happens or not because he can force his terms on team Pacquiao. This fight could have elevated boxing as a sport in 2010.
Not saying Manny has no fault in this (or Arum) but Floyd's legacy is hurt more by not fighting Manny then the other way around.

[Elotero]

i agree. but he didnt do it d. you cant give him credit for hypothetical victories. when he was cleaning up 130, just below him you had names like marquez, barerra, pacquiao, morales, hamed.


at 135 he faced castillo but he didnt face casamayor or stevie johnston. 2 slick fighters. yet pac gets harped on for not facing slick fighters?

floyd's brimming with talent but his resume is really bare compared to other ATG fighters.

What about The Pooch not doing anything @ 135 besides beating David Diaz?

@135 JLCastillo >>>>>>>>> David Diaz

[DeadLikeMe]

What about The Pooch not doing anything @ 135 besides beating David Diaz?

@135 JLCastillo >>>>>>>>> David Diaz

Hey now, David Diaz had the longest winning streak of any Pacquiao opponent since Barrera...he had won 5 in a row going into the Pac fight.

[TOBYLEE1]

I geuss never saw the rise of Corrales.