If Joe Calzaghe was in the Super Six.........

[ippo]

when he was at 168 he beats them all.Its funny when people say ward or dirrel would beat him.

[Ryn0]

He'd beat Froch,Kessler and Abraham ( if he can take his punches ),he'd TKO Green

But stylisticly,i can see Ward giving him problems and beating him in a close fight,and i can see Dirrell causing him major problems and defeating him,id choose Dirrell over Calzaghe,stlyles makes fights,Dirrell knows how to fight on the outside and make u miss,Calzaghe throws alot of flurrys without much power Dirrell could just counter him all night,lets not forget,Calzaghe looked bad against Bika,who held him,and roughed him up,he also got KD by Bhop and Jones,whens the last time they dropped someone anyway?

Hopkins dropped Tarver, Jones stopped Lacy, dropped Trinidad, Hanshaw.

They can still punch.

[daggum]

Now or prime Joe? Now he may have some tough fights, but I would still favor him to beat anyone in it. Prime he wins all of them.

didn't prime calzaghe get a gift decision against robin reid? not sure how that "prime" calzaghe would beat a technician like ward but miracles can happen i guess. when was his prime anyway? was his prime when he was struggling against guys like washed up charles brewer and fighting no hopers like tocker pudwill?

[dans]

Just assume that Joe Calzaghe was in the tourney say instead of Taylor, how do you think he would have done? I personally think he beats them all. Thoughts anyone?

Probably would've pulled out with an injury. lol

IDK, maybe he'd be winning, maybe not.

[PittyPat]

He would beat Kessler again, and easily clown Froch. Green I haven't watched yet. Abraham... 50-50 fight, and there's a big chance he'd get KO'ed on the way in. Both Dirrell and Ward would SD him.

[daggum]

Probably would've pulled out with an injury. lol

IDK, maybe he'd be winning, maybe not.

the tournament would take 8 years to finish if he was allowed in but he would never enter unless the other guys were mario veit, juan carlos giminez ferrari, mger mtchkian, will mcyintre, and tocker pudwill. top super middleweights right?

[carlos slim]

the tournament would take 8 years to finish if he was allowed in but he would never enter unless the other guys were mario veit, juan carlos giminez ferrari, mger mtchkian, will mcyintre, and tocker pudwill. top super middleweights right?

haha at taking 8 years to finish....