Most controversial fight/robbery you have ever seen?

[JK1700]

I can only remember a few

Sven Ottke over Robin Reid

J.C Chavez "draw" with Pernell Whitaker

RJJ in the Olympics

Oscar De La Hoya over Felix Sturm

Which fights can you remember and which was the biggest robbery?

[W1LL]

To be honest, I thought Jermain Taylor vs. Cory Spinks was a robbery.

Also, Paul Williams vs. Sergio Martinez.

And of course Manny Pacquiao's "win" and "draw" over Juan Manuel Marquez, and his second "win" over Marco Antonio Barrera.

[JK1700]

Bump.......

[JK1700]

To be honest, I thought Jermain Taylor vs. Cory Spinks was a robbery.

Also, Paul Williams vs. Sergio Martinez.

And of course Manny Pacquiao's "win" and "draw" over Juan Manuel Marquez, and his second "win" over Marco Antonio Barrera.

I havent seen Taylor-Spinks but I heard Cory used a really negative style and thats why he lost. But if you win then you win, I guess I will have to check that one out and see for myself.

I dont think you can call Williams-Martinez a robbery, It was a close fight. But the 119-110 scorecard was a disgrace to boxing. That was the kind of fight that could have gone either way

Pacquiao Marquez I, I scored it a draw but the 2nd fight was a ROBBERY. Marquez won clearly. Once again I havent seen Pacquiao-Barrera II. The scorecards were like 118-109. Did you really think Barrera won?

I thought Barrera beat Marquez in their fight...

[Kaspa9t9]

To be honest, I thought Jermain Taylor vs. Cory Spinks was a robbery.

Also, Paul Williams vs. Sergio Martinez.

And of course Manny Pacquiao's "win" and "draw" over Juan Manuel Marquez, and his second "win" over Marco Antonio Barrera.

You thought Pacman's second win over Barrera was a robbery?

[JK1700]

You thought Pacman's second win over Barrera was a robbery?

I havent seen it so I dont know. You look at the scorecard of 118-109 and you think he won clearly but thats not always the case. 118-109 I think was the score twice for JMM's win over Barrera. I had Barrera winning 114-113

[Kaspa9t9]

Talking about bad judging, the Judge who scored the fight 97-92 for Prescott against Vasquez is an absolute DISGRACE.

[JK1700]

The worst piece of judging EVER...

Franz Marti had Sven Ottke beating Robin Reid 117-112

Absolute DISGRACE

[Kaspa9t9]

I havent seen it so I dont know. You look at the scorecard of 118-109 and you think he won clearly but thats not always the case. 118-109 I think was the score twice for JMM's win over Barrera. I had Barrera winning 114-113

Wait, are you talking about MAB-JMM II or Pacman-MAB II?

[JK1700]

Wait, are you talking about MAB-JMM II or Pacman-MAB II?

The other guy said he thought Pacquiao-Barrera II was controversial and you where like "what?". My point is that although the margin was wide it doesnt always mean the guy truly won the fight. Juan Manuel Marquez won 118-109 on two scorecards in his fight with Marco Antonio Barrera. I thought that was a very close fight that Barrera won 114-113