Joe Calzaghe vs Lucian Bute: Now @168-WHO WINS?

[boxasmash]

Calzaghe is 38, he is probably shot now too...

[Cash Cow]

Make it at 175.

who wins at that weight?

[Cash Cow]

Calzaghe never fought someone with head movement like Bute, intriguing match up. Workrate isn't effective against someone like Bute who understands distance better than anybody. Calzaghe might pull it off because of his 1000 punches but would look like **** in the process, like Williams against Sergio.

Andrade hit Bute alot

[Cash Cow]

At first I thought Bute was a generic Calzaghe, but his last couple of fights have impressed me. I agree with Mark on this I think Bute may have something special.

against Andrade & Miranda?

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Joe with a 2 year lay off at 38 trying to squeeze down to 168.

Aint happening.

[street bully]

Calzaghe is still 37 and doesn't have much miles. Calzaghe humliates Bute.

[boxasmash]

By the way, if you mean Prime Calzaghe then Joe all the way, Calzaghe won the IBF,WBO,WBA,WBC, Ring Magazine Super Middleweight titles and Ring Light Heavyweight title making 21 title defences in the process. What has Bute done which even comes close? Calzaghe is **** on too much, you don't do all that if you're not a great fighter.

Prime Calzaghe>>>> Bute.

[Ryn0]

Calzaghe probably couldn't make 168 now, and we don't know how the layoff has affected him.

I say Bute butthe Calzaghe of 2-3 years ago would've won.

[boxasmash]

Calzaghe is still 37 and doesn't have much miles. Calzaghe humliates Bute.

He's 38 and has been taking ******* for the past 3 years according to Frank Warren.

[AKATheMack]

against Andrade & Miranda?

I wasnt impressed with who he beat, but how he looked while beating them. He hadnt looked that good beating lesser fighters than Andrade and Miranda.