Calzaghe and Pacquiao, resume to resume.

[Shadow boxer 3]

I cant argue with anything you said here. The only thing I would change is

Bika > Clottey other than that you are spot on.

of course, comin from another calzaghe fan

[W1LL]

No one can argue because it is true. If you disagree, either put the resume's together like I did in the original post or stfu and gtfo. Thanks.

[Shadow boxer 3]

No one can argue because it is true. If you disagree, either put the resume's together like I did in the original post or stfu and gtfo. Thanks.

[Check]

Hopkins was never better than Marquez and neither is Kessler over Cotto. Kessler has been in what, one or two big fights leading up to the Calzaghe bout, compared to Cotto, his resume is no where near the same nor is he a proven fighter imo. I do agree with the Bika/Clottey and might even say Bika is better than Clottey. All in all the resumes aren't even close to the same.

[Joeyzagz]

of course, comin from another calzaghe fan

Why dont you lay out your reasons as to why you think Pac has a better resume'?


Calzaghe defeated everyone he ever faced, you can not take that away from him.

[the niggest]

Why dont you lay out your reasons as to why you think Pac has a better resume'?


Calzaghe defeated everyone he ever faced, you can not take that away from him.

So did Julio Cesar Chavez Jr and Sven Ottke...

Calzaghe is nowhere near Pacquiao when it comes to resume, ability or greatness.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

A compelling case.

[SoldierWarrior]

So did Julio Cesar Chavez Jr and Sven Ottke...

Calzaghe is nowhere near Pacquiao when it comes to resume, ability or greatness.

You look on boxrec too much, boxrec is incorrect Ottke has a couple of losses and same with Chavez Jr. Don't ever trust boxrec, its inaccurate. And Chavez Jr has a couple of losses to weak opposition, Chavez Jr. has gotten boo'd before since several times the decision went the wrong way. Undefeated my ass.

[the niggest]

You look on boxrec too much, boxrec is incorrect Ottke has a couple of losses and same with Chavez Jr. Don't ever trust boxrec, its inaccurate.

Yes I know but so what? They have undeafeted records just like Calzaghe.

But ok what about Zsolt Erdei? I guess since he is undeafeted he must be an ATG?

Look, Calzaghe was a good fighter but not an all time great. His resume is nothing compared to Pacquiao.

[Boxin']

Pacquiao's wins over Barrera and Morales are better than anything on Calzaghe's resume. As I stated in my original post. Know your role, ****wit.

Pacquiao climbed up 7 weight divisions, how many did Calzaghe climb? 2?

Pac beating Barrera at 126 and then dominating Cotto at 145 is like Calzaghe dominating a top heavyweight...