If Margarito rematches Shane, and wins,

[Sweet Pea 50]

Funny how this thread is almost 4 pages and hardly any answers.

Funny how a fu.cking noob think's this thread is on the fourth page. You want an answer? Marg gets his ass clowned by PWill again, rematch with Cotto, then get's took to school by Mayweather. Happy?

[firstborn]

Yes Margarito should get credit for beating Mosley in a rematch. For him to beat Mosely he would have to revamp his style and overcome the mind **** of facing the person who KO'd him. Mosely is no longer part of the elite, but he's still a dangerous fighter with lots of experience and KO power.

[Mr. Fantastic]

Funny how a fu.cking noob think's this thread is on the fourth page. You want an answer? Marg gets his ass clowned by PWill again, rematch with Cotto, then get's took to school by Mayweather. Happy?

Funny how you missed the word "almost".

[dannyl15]

you people will say that Mosley is old, and it tie it in to downplay Mayweather's win, and if it was @ 54 they would still say the same thing only they would say Mosley is not a jr middleweight even though I feel like is.

[cletoreyes147]

I used to think Margarito would beat Shane in a rematch (since he seemed weight drained against Mosley), but after watching him on Saturday I realized he is done. Margarito should not be fighting anymore; he is a lot slower than he was before (is that possible?) and at 154 he has no power. Should he face a top 154 fighter, he will get destroyed.

[FLY TY]

how much credit does he get?

he gets credit in my book...but there are 2 problems....


1) margarito is still suspended.

2) shane has NO reason to take that fight. he can get a fight w/ anybody NOT named pacquiao or mayweather.

[Da Hammer]

he will never fight in the u.s again so BOOK IT. mexico may support his behavior but in the U.S we do not support criminals who were willing to risk killing a person for sucess they couldnt achieve by fair means.

yet people support mosley among many other "cheaters" in sports. u don't think mosley using PED helped him be stronger and be in better condition, which equals in greater pain for his opponents?

[Eaner0919]

and there is it.

Most people can't even discuss a simple matter without getting emotional, so they have to bring up **** that has been discussed thousands of times already.

We know he was caught doing something that wasn't right. Fine. We get that.


Thats not the issue here though,

I asked a simple question,

If Margarito was to rematch Shane and win, does he get credit?




I think most don't want to truthfully answer and say no. They don't want to answer because then they'll have to remember that Shane is 38.


If they don't give Margarito credit, they'll have to renounce the credit gave to another fighter who just beat Shane.

I actually answered your question TW

[Da Hammer]

he gets credit in my book...but there are 2 problems....


1) margarito is still suspended.

2) shane has NO reason to take that fight. he can get a fight w/ anybody NOT named pacquiao or mayweather.

you make a good point with 1 although i would be shocked if he wasn't reinstated soon. But for 2 i disagree. Being a floyd fan yo should know that money talks and we all know mosley has been desperate for money. and fighting margarito honestly makes him more money than any other fight out there...

[Calilloyd]

and there is it.

Most people can't even discuss a simple matter without getting emotional, so they have to bring up **** that has been discussed thousands of times already.

We know he was caught doing something that wasn't right. Fine. We get that.


Thats not the issue here though,

I asked a simple question,

If Margarito was to rematch Shane and win, does he get credit?



I think most don't want to truthfully answer and say no. They don't want to answer because then they'll have to remember that Shane is 38.


If they don't give Margarito credit, they'll have to renounce the credit gave to another fighter who just beat Shane.

****** questions don't deserve a legitimate response. And the answer is obvious. Of course he would get credit. Maybe if 100 percent of your threads didn't have your agenda, you would get a straight response. The bigger question should be, did you give Mosley credit for beating Margarito? Or did you consider Mosley "shot" afterwards for your convenience?