Sports Illustrated P4P: "Mayweather is #1"

[wazaa.]

Yes I agree. Floyd beating past prime Mosley > Pacquiao beating past prime Cotto.

[M.I.C.]

If Pac got a problem with being demoted then get in the ring and do something about it.

[M.I.C.]

Yes I agree. Floyd beating past prime Mosley > Pacquiao beating past prime Cotto.

One thing is certain, Mosley didn't get his azz whipped by Margarito.

[SkilledB]

hmmm... Pac just beat dangerous fighters, no biggie.

Mayweather beat a HOF'r thats past his prime, sounds about right.

Pac beat a HOF'r thats past him prime as well im DLH

[Boss Don]

If Pac got a problem with being demoted then get in the ring and do something about it.

I agree with this 100%

[etlux]

Yes I agree. Floyd beating past prime Mosley > Pacquiao beating past prime Cotto.

1. Pac made Cotto drain to 145 and looked dehydrated and Cotto was coming off a destruction to Margarito and flat victory over Clottey

2. PBF beat a big shane at his natural weight class, Shane was coming off 2 KTFO destructions of other top champions.

[Tata Moran]

I agree.. Floyd left boxing while he was on TOP, Manny claimed the top spot. Now that Floyd is back and just displayed an ass whooping against Mosley who is TOP 3 P4P, he deserves to reclaim the TOP p4p status.

[Ray*]

They would both decide it in the ring!

[And Still]

Is Miguel Cotto a Hall of Famer?

[jrosales13]

Is Miguel Cotto a Hall of Famer?

No, but there are fighters in the HOF who should not be in the HOF.

And, I don't care what anybody says. His career is not over yet. We will see how he looks with Steward in his corner.