Floyd is GOAT already??

[Pirao]

Of course not, don't be silly. But, he's the best of this era, I think he beats Pacquiao too, and I like Pacquiao better, but Floyd is too good IMO.

[Uturn]

?? you aint goat till your retired....and theres only one "GOAT" sugar ray robinson son, mayweather needs to worry about pac before any of this mess is said.

What if he beat pacquiao? Is he GOAT then? Or what does he have to do to gain that status?

[brick wall]

I havent seen ONE person says hes the GOAT. Not one.

floyd said it himself foo...greater than ali or srr remember? you're all over his nuts 24/7 and you don't know

[Pirao]

What if he beat pacquiao? Is he GOAT then? Or what does he have to do to gain that status?

To be GOAT he would need to win belts all the way to LHW, or something like that.

[Pretty Boy Greg]

Im getting this vibe round BS at the moment and it almost sounds as though he's unbeatable & invincible.. Is it true y'all think he's GOAT after his win over Mosley? I see alot of people have jumped on the bandwagon of Mayweather after the fight, even some suggesting he's surpassed the likes of Ali.. So is Mayweather GOAT now?

beat packy, sergio and pwill and lets say khan or alvarez and he is top 3... destroy them all like he did to sugar and he is my GOAT...

[mines a pasty]

Im getting this vibe round BS at the moment and it almost sounds as though he's unbeatable & invincible.. Is it true y'all think he's GOAT after his win over Mosley? I see alot of people have jumped on the bandwagon of Mayweather after the fight, even some suggesting he's surpassed the likes of Ali.. So is Mayweather GOAT now?

no point fighting Manny then eh?

[Bogler]

What if he beat pacquiao? Is he GOAT then? Or what does he have to do to gain that status?

he passed on that chance when he retired and all the top WWs were slugging it out, then came back and still avoided a WW for a bloated FW. im pretty sure he wont fight pwill or martinez, it's all smokescreen.

[AKATheMack]

Roberto Durans close UD loss to Hagler is better than any win on Floyds resume.

[Pretty Boy Greg]

floyd can never be the goat of boxing only a goat of his era. anyone that thinks any different doesn't know boxing.

If thats the case I will say he is GOAT of his era but not all time

[Boxin']

Im getting this vibe round BS at the moment and it almost sounds as though he's unbeatable & invincible.. Is it true y'all think he's GOAT after his win over Mosley? I see alot of people have jumped on the bandwagon of Mayweather after the fight, even some suggesting he's surpassed the likes of Ali.. So is Mayweather GOAT now?

Vernon Forrest was GOAT after he beat prime Shane Mosley

And then Mayorga became GOAT after knocking Forrest out... looool