Marquez being #3 p4p is a disgrace!

[Earl-Hickey]

he's a natural featherweight going up to fight lightweights and welterweight.

you're gonna hold a loss to a welterweight against him?

well, yeah I am actually, In the last 14 months, Marquez has won 1 round, does that qualify him to be #3 of the best boxers in the world? not in my opinion, if he wins against Diaz easily, then maybe you could make an argument, but I think activity has to be a big part of the p4p rankings.

Marquez may be a good boxer, but what has he done recently, not much really.

[Eric Holder]

I think wlad should be number 3. They always ignore heavyweights in p4p. Wlad is dominating his division and his skills are undeniable regardless of his actual weight.

Why people will say that the likes of Cotto or williams are more skilled that wladimir i just dont understand.

And right now, wladimir is more skilled than JMM, I said it. JMM deserves credit for his last two KO wins but he also took a lot of shots in return, Wladimir is better today because his defense is so much better and he consistently has been winning every minute of every round.

Yeah I know the division is weak, but Hopkins gets his credit for 20 defenses of a weak middleweight division so wlad deserves his credit.

disagree, JMM's an undersized lightweight and he was able to ko to highly rated lightweights (Casamayor and Diaz) and he jumped up two divisons to fight the best boxer on the planet. Wlad's dwarfed most of his opponents and he relies on pretty much just on 1's and 2'

[Kobe B Bryant]

well, yeah I am actually, In the last 14 months, Marquez has won 1 round, does that qualify him to be #3 of the best boxers in the world? not in my opinion, if he wins against Diaz easily, then maybe you could make an argument, but I think activity has to be a big part of the p4p rankings.

Marquez may be a good boxer, but what has he done recently, not much really.

if mayweather can get #1 p4p by fighting a blown up 35 yr. old featherweight and a 40 yr. old welterweight......

marquez can get #3 p4p even having a loss to a welterweight as a natural featherweight.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

I agree get his ass off the list.

Hes fighting a shot Diaz, then wants a shot Hatton and a shot Morales. Im a fan of JMM but thats just unacceptable.

[Pullcounter]

Honestly, whats he done to deserve that, been obliterated by money may, and been outboxed by Juan Diaz before getting lucky, and now he's rematching diaz, who just lost twice to Paulie Maglinaggi, who is about to fight amir khan.

it makes my head hurt!

#3 is somewhat high.

[¤¤¤]

3 may be high, but both marquez's and diaz's recent losses weren't at their best weights.

does anybody take skill set into consideration when compiling p4p lists anymore?

[BigStereotype]

Honestly, whats he done to deserve that, been obliterated by money may, and been outboxed by Juan Diaz before getting lucky, and now he's rematching diaz, who just lost twice to Paulie Maglinaggi, who is about to fight amir khan.

it makes my head hurt!

Lucky? He was carving up Diaz's defense for the last few rounds like it wasn't even there. He started off taking more punches than he should have, but he made his adjustments and earned that KO. Man can ****ing fight. Maybe not #3, but definitely top 5.

[RoyJonesJrp4pno1]

Honestly, whats he done to deserve that, been obliterated by money may, and been outboxed by Juan Diaz before getting lucky, and now he's rematching diaz, who just lost twice to Paulie Maglinaggi, who is about to fight amir khan.

it makes my head hurt!

He was robbed against Pac

[Iceta Lives]

well, he has done alot more than paul williams i can tell you that

Are you sure about that? Martinez has went on to do something meaningful. What have Casamayor or Diaz done here lately?

[Scott9945]

I agree get his ass off the list.

Hes fighting a shot Diaz, then wants a shot Hatton and a shot Morales. Im a fan of JMM but thats just unacceptable.

This time I agree with you. JMM looks like he is winding down his career. The PPV rematch with Diaz will be a dud because both fighters have slipped since they fought on regular HBO. Matches against Hatton or Morales are for those who like to live in the past.