If Shane fights and KO's Berto...

[Afactor4]

Would people still downplay PBF's victory as much as they are doing now?

Yeah I think Berto's overrated and will be out of there surprisingly soon, but does this suggest Mosley is still a world class fighter and therefore not past it like some people here think he is.

[roe]

I doubt Shane would KO Andre Berto at this stage but no it wouldn't change my opinion of the fight with Mayweather anyway. Floyd fought a guy who was past his best and inactive but that said, did previously beat the number 1 guy in the welterweight division. Clearly a fight against Manny Pacquiao would be tougher but to be fair, Mosley was definitely the next best fight available.

[geribeetus]

they would, they always will.

i agree berto's overrated but he's not bad. shane could still get him out of there.

[baracuda]

give berto a fight with margo and he gets stopped.....berto aint all that....

[Afactor4]

give berto a fight with margo and he gets stopped.....berto aint all that....

I know that. But if Shane fought him and beat him, would people give Pretty Boy Floyd more credit for his win over Mosley.

Because right now his incredible and resillient performance is being overshadowed by posters calling on Shane's age, inactivity etc...

[DR.ORGYY]

he would still beat berto imo......pac and mayweather are just in there own leagues rite now.....