whos greater floyd or roy

[Toney616]

and who would win if they fought ?

Resume wise Floyd

[SplitSecond]

Before Roy's chin was finally esposed I would have said Roy while acknowleging Floyd had better overall boxing skills. Now I would have to say Floyd p4p because at some point he would land something on Roy's chin.

you think floyd could ko prime roy?

[boxmaniac123]

I think at some point in the fight Floyd would ask the question of Roy's chin. Both guys are great and would be a tough fight to score. If latter-day Floyd shows up (more willing to mix it up and with more power) I would say he tests Roy at some point. On the other hand if young Floyd (more focused on defense due to being trained by Floyd Snr) shows up I think Roy outpoints him.

[Fists_of_Fury]

Floyd since he's fought a little better opposition. Floyd will end his career undefeated also. If they fought... Floyd would get ko'd at any weight if it were prime RJJ. If they fought now I think Floyd by UD.

[General Zod]

In terms of resume I have to go with Floyd, as for a mythical matchup no comment

[murmagic]

floyd higher atg but roy would beat him in a fight

[Dambala]

Floyd has a better run, he should be higher in any ATG list. On fighting each other, I don't know coz the weight gap is huge.

[SugarRoyJones]

Before Roy's chin was finally esposed I would have said Roy while acknowleging Floyd had better overall boxing skills. Now I would have to say Floyd p4p because at some point he would land something on Roy's chin.

Roy's chin wasnt exposed. He just wasn't a lightheavyweight anymore when Tarver got to him. In Roy Jones prime he beats everybody in your Top 10 all-time P4P. I'm not biased. ;-)

[boxmaniac123]

Maybe I am wrong but could have sworn Jones vs Tarver was at 175...

[Boxin']

Roy is much bigger than Floyd.