Who has a more impressive win?

[AdamantiumPI]

Who had the more impressive win, Pac over Cotto or Mayweather over Mosley? People argue that Cotto was shot after his loss to Margarito and was drained at 145 lbs. Cotto beat Mosley and Mosley beat Margarito but many believe Margarito wasn't himself because of the hand wrap incident. Mosley is 38 years old, gassed in this fight and looked past his prime.

Pac looked like a beast in his win over a game Cotto that was competitive during the early rounds of the fight. Mayweather schooled Mosley after getting rocked twice in the second round. Both fighters showed greatness after going through some tough rounds early in their fights. Who looked more impressive in these wins?

[rochemback]

I still think Pac over Cotto. Obviously, you can make a case for both and both have question marks if you search long enough and badly want to find some, but just from a personal point of view, the destruction of Cotto, who was retreating for a good number of rounds was shocking and impressive at the same time.

That doesn't take anything away from Mayweather's win and I still lean towards him if he ever meets Pac in what would definitely be a great fight.

[AdamantiumPI]

BTW I think Cotto still has it. Cotto showed heart in his fight with Manny. Mosley gassed early, lost confidence during the fight and seemed to give up. Mayweather may have that effect on people because of his skills. But I think Pac had a tougher and more determined opponent in front of him in Cotto.

[Sick/]

Cotto obv. Mosley was old and inactive

[blacksocks]

The way Mosley was at his fight with Floyd, I'm confident Pac would have stopped him.