If Floyd wins tonight, does he go > Sugar Ray Robinson

[boxingfan_123]

take your opinion to some experts and see what they say

[STRUGG]

hey *******, pacman is even further behind SRR's legacy than Floyd is so calm down

lol.........from a person who doesnt know how great duran is...........lol..........you sure have that superiority complex............wrong again in your assessmeent fool........lol

[etlux]

lol.........from a person who doesnt know how great duran is...........lol..........you sure have that superiority complex............wrong again in your assessmeent fool........lol

I know how great Duran is, I just questioned his greatness as compared to the other Fab 4 guys. Duran is greater than both Pac and Floyd at this point that's for sure

[STRUGG]

I know how great Duran is, I just questioned his greatness as compared to the other Fab 4 guys. Duran is greater than both Pac and Floyd at this point that's for sure

fair...........but floyds legacy aint greater than pac...............4 lineals.....7 titles.............................skillwise would go to floyd..........................................

[fugu]

that would be some ******* logic.

No, Floyd would not overtake SRR. He wont even be close.

Neither is Pacquiao. Not even ****ing close.

[etlux]

fair...........but floyds legacy aint greater than pac...............4 lineals.....7 titles.............................skillwise would go to floyd..........................................

it's unfair to say who's greater on the night of the big fight because that legacy is bound to change for better or worse in literally 2 hours. So what I mean is, if Floyd DESTROYS Shane tonight, he is arguably greater than Pac. If he loses then obviously Pac is greater. The reason is that I feel they are so close legacy wise at this moment that the tipping point is riding on this fight tonight.

[Cadillac Man]

He could KO Mosley in the 1st round an he still ain't even in the same breath as robinson.

[STRUGG]

it's unfair to say who's greater on the night of the big fight because that legacy is bound to change for better or worse in literally 2 hours. So what I mean is, if Floyd DESTROYS Shane tonight, he is arguably greater than Pac. If he loses then obviously Pac is greater. The reason is that I feel they are so close legacy wise at this moment that the tipping point is riding on this fight tonight.

i disagree...........if floyd gattis shane and pac.....and closes the show with a legit 154............he definitely is.....floyd needs to make up for them 2 years..........PAC captured/dared to be greater.....why cant floyd????.........

[etlux]

i disagree...........if floyd gattis shane and pac.....and closes the show with a legit 154............he definitely is.....floyd needs to make up for them 2 years..........PAC captured/dared to be greater.....why cant floyd????.........

because floyd was capturing and daring to be great years ago when Pac was fighting bums that's why so it evens out.

Floyd won just as many titles in weight classes as Pac so what are you talking about. If Floyd beats Shane you better believe he's greater than Pac considering he's achieved as much give or take but without taking a single loss whereas Pac got KTFO multiple times.
Now don't get me wrong I don't buy into that "0" **** on its own, but when it's dead even that "0" gives Floyd that mystique that Pac lacks and pulls him ahead by just enough. Floyd still has never lost all while accomplishing as much or almost as much as Pac (if he beats Shane tonight) whereas Pac accomplished but was KTFO twice in the process and got owned multiple times, lost to Morales 1, arguably lost twice to JMM, etc, etc.

[STRUGG]

because floyd was capturing and daring to be great years ago when Pac was fighting bums that's why so it evens out.

Floyd won just as many titles in weight classes as Pac so what are you talking about. If Floyd beats Shane you better believe he's greater than Pac considering he's achieved as much give or take but without taking a single loss whereas Pac got KTFO multiple times.
Now don't get me wrong I don't buy into that "0" **** on its own, but when it's dead even that "0" gives Floyd that mystique that Pac lacks and pulls him ahead by just enough. Floyd still has never lost all while accomplishing as much or almost as much as Pac (if he beats Shane tonight) whereas Pac accomplished but was KTFO twice in the process and got owned multiple times, lost to Morales 1, arguably lost twice to JMM, etc, etc.

hell no...............floyd is just in this race because of his .....pre WW....achievement..................back in the days when he was a beast.......................so floyd potshotting a 38 year old is greater for you..............than a former flyweight destroying arguably the #1 or 2 in the WW........in cotto....and winning against clottey.............that doesnt cut it for me....i anint looking for a KO.....i want some combinations......and solid offence....we all know floyd has a great defense....show us a new dimension of his game then.........