Pound 4 Pound Champ Mayweather or Hopkins?

[onetwopunch]

Hopkins is no doubt.

[onetwopunch]

Hopkins, although nearing 41 is still the best pound for pound fighter. We havent seen Jermain Taylor against elite competition yet so if he beats Hopkins hed be up there. As far as Hatton, he proved that he is the truth. He beat what many experts say was the best pound for pound fighter.

I cant wait for that fight..Taylor has never fought anyone as strong and technically sound as Hopkins.

[CH0ZEN]

Thanks for the (Uncle) Roger Mayweather slap my bad that's what happens at 2 am; And I still have to say the tried, tested and true Hopkins still has the crown here. Taylor has a shot to really change things in the P4P area as quickly as Pacman did. But lets not forget Hopkins is a fighter and a boxer and a puncher and hasn't appeared to be stoppable ever since finally shaking of the "Roid" Jones jr masacre. Roy is one of my all time favs and is on my P4P alltime list but the guy had to be on something.

[Tha Greatest]

Taylor to be #1 has to beat Hopkins and Wright

Hopkins is old as **** now so a win over Hopkins won't mean much

All I know is that a prime Hopkins would OWN Taylor....

[CH0ZEN]

I must admit, until I saw first hand what Mayweather is capable of when he trains hard, and with the insane amount of potential I saw in Floyd recently I had said Hopkins. And Hopkins will defend his claim vs. Taylor I have very little doubt if any at all there. But I have to be honest, (the undefeated) Mayweather is the closest thing to being a dominating P4P King since Roy Jones jr. and is the NEW P4P champion of the world! When Hatton goes to sleep what does Mayweather have to do to convince the rest of you?

[E.T.]

Still Hopkins for me.
Mayweather needs some more
bigtime wins to surpass or equal Hopkins

[CH0ZEN]

I agree Mayweather will need more testing until he can be an undoubted legend. But I also have no doubt if he trains like he did for Gatti this guy will clean out the 147 lb division, after he is finished at 140. That's when people start comparing him to the Sugarz - "Sugar" Ray Robinson and "Sugar" Ray Leonard and Mayweather getz his due. That is if he stays sane and out of jail.

[Konstantin]

Mayweather.

Hes been dominating his opponents for the most part and has a much nice list of opposition. And I think if they were in the same weight class Floyd would have his way with Hopkins. Hes just a better boxer. He has more skill and more speed/reflexes.