Why do you believe Castillo won the first fight with Floyd?

[johnm is...]

because he won the majority of teh 12 rds .

Apparently not.

[Eric Holder]

If a close fight results in a robbery, then why can't a clear win result in handing one his ass?

I think I'm finally starting to catch on to the ways of NSB.

actually that's exactly how almost every close fight and rematch are described on here it's not like it's just Floyd who's held to that standard

I've seen plenty of people say that about

Chavez vs. Taylor 1 = robbery and 2= domination
Diaz vs. Paulie 1 = robbery and 2 = domination


I'm just pointing out that it's untrue

[bojangles1987]

Because he destroyed Floyd to the body in the middle rounds and outworked him in the later rounds. I don't have a huge problem with people who think Floyd won, but those scorecards were ridiculous.

[johnm is...]

actually that's exactly how almost every close fight and rematch are described on here it's not like it's just Floyd who's held to that standard

I've seen plenty of people say that about

Chavez vs. Taylor 1 = robbery and 2= domination
Diaz vs. Paulie 1 = robbery and 2 = domination


I'm just pointing out that it's untrue

Yeah. I wasn't directing the actual comment toward you. I just quoted you.

[gqjohnb]

I can see how people can say castillo won, I had it for floyd by two rounds, but a robbery?? Anyway this is a dead issue. Floyd was injured in that fight and he beat him easily in the rematch.

[Dynamite Kid]

because he outlanded and outworked floyd in a majority of the rounds. not a robbery, but the young prospect got the nod, it's something that happens surprisingly often.

This^^^^^

Mayweather's inactivity hurt him more than anything, plus Castillo was able to get off when he became a stationary target which made him use his legs even more, which obviously effects your punch output.

[Vasyl’s dad]

if thats the case why didnt castillo outwork floyd in the rematch? he got his ass handed to him in the rematch dont see no one talking about that

What does Paul Williams first round KO of Carlos Quintana have to do with Quintanas 12 round decision over Williams?

Nothing,

but you're still quite dumb.


What does Rafa Marquez 7th round stoppage over Israel Vazquez have to do with Izzy stopping Rafa in the 6th round in the rematch?


Nothing,



but you're still quite dumb.

[Jim Jeffries]

actually that's exactly how almost every close fight and rematch are described on here it's not like it's just Floyd who's held to that standard

I've seen plenty of people say that about

Chavez vs. Taylor 1 = robbery and 2= domination
Diaz vs. Paulie 1 = robbery and 2 = domination


I'm just pointing out that it's untrue

Diaz outlanded Paulie in 6 rounds of their first fight, so robbery is absurd.

The first Castillo fight wasn't a robbery, as I only had him winning 7 rounds. But the neat, clear cut 8 rounds to 4 scores for Floyd were highly su****ious. And you could see the look on Floyd's face where he knew he lost the fight.