Could Pacquiao go through Mayweather's resume undefeated?

[War Dinamita]

Castillo would beat his ass and JMM already out-boxed Manny.

[Kagami Taiga]

Oh my goodness this is just getting ridiculous

glad to see someone with a level head...i dunno how anyone does this goin thru another's resume stuff, especially when both fighter took very different paths to the top. there's just so much you got to take into account. the weight classes, the time when each was i the divisions, the skills of the fightes when they were in those divisions and the skills of the fighters they were fighting at the time. you cant just look at how both fighters are today and assume they could have won back then. both mayweather and pac were quite different fighters when they were comin up as opposed to now when they are on top.

[baracuda]

Castillo would beat his ass and JMM already out-boxed Manny.

pac would never get koed by hatton.........jmm did'nt beat ****..he could've even deck packy..........

[War Dinamita]

pac would never get koed by hatton.........jmm did'nt beat ****..he could've even deck packy..........

Castillo was shot against Hatton and was past his prime. I hope you don't think a prime Castillo fought Hatton, lmao.

JMM out-boxed his ass for two fights.

[-GDS-]

Hopefully my thread doesn't slip into the abyss of tardedness.

[baracuda]

Castillo was shot against Hatton and was past his prime. I hope you don't think a prime Castillo fought Hatton, lmao.

JMM out-boxed his ass for two fights.

sure....you keep believin that but pac beat jmm once and arguably twice......they dont call him the mexicutuiner for nothing!

[daggum]

Castillo would beat his ass and JMM already out-boxed Manny.

the same castillo who was ko'd twice by this guy(the guy on the ground)



i wonder why floyd never fought freitas? probably not enough ppv buys or something

[F l i c k e r]

you wish....even cloteey beats all them guys...oh wait,he already beat corrales, who is floyds' biggest win...lol......floyd better beat all of pac's past oppenets since he's way bigger than them but ...i would'nt count cotto out......

Just by mentioning Clottey... you fail.

Cotto would get out boxed by Mayweather. We all know it. Cotto knows it which is why he didn't press the issue of fighting Mayweather. Arum knows it. Even pre-Margarito Cotto would have been out boxed and pot shot to an easy UD. Cotto fades in the championship rounds, he would continuosly be pot shot. He wouldn't be able to avoid Mayweather like he did Mosley.

What weight would he fight Pac opponents in? At the same weight that Pac fought them in? Why are you guys not putting weight-class in effect?

Well in the 1st page the TS stated that it would be same weight classes.

Which means he would fight JLC, Genaro, and Corrales at the weight class where he had horrible technique. So it wouldn't be the Pacquiao we seen destroy Hatton, ODLH, and Cotto. It would be the guy who struggled with Morales and Marquez.

That's a bold statement. Why do you think that?

Pacquiao wouldn't beat Corrales. Corrales would obliterate Pacquiao. Too tall, too dangerous, and Pacquiao's style fits right into Corrales' style. Corrales was beat by Mayweather's slick tendencies, able to avoid and cause damage. Pacquiao was a one dimentional in your face guy and those guys get the **** kicked out of him by Corrales. And it's not like Pacquiao has a granite chin, so in a straight war, Corrales would walk away the victor.

Jose Luis Castillo would break Pacquiao down. Big body ****er, Pacquiao's body had already been proven to be weak. Pacquiao would need a JMM controversial decision to beat JLC. I don't see Pacquiao going far after taking shots to the body instead of the face. Start slowing down late rounds and then crumble from there on out.

Pacquiao wouldn't beat Genaro Hernandez either. That version of Pacquiao was too undisciplined, he would have been killed by the seasoned vet. You think the guy who beat Azumah Nelson would lose to a version of Pacquiao that got outboxed by Morales? No.

[BrushMyCage]

how many slick boxers did hasegawa face?

[-GDS-]

Pacquiao wouldn't beat Corrales. Corrales would obliterate Pacquiao. Too tall, too dangerous, and Pacquiao's style fits right into Corrales' style. Corrales was beat by Mayweather's slick tendencies, able to avoid and cause damage. Pacquiao was a one dimentional in your face guy and those guys get the **** kicked out of him by Corrales. And it's not like Pacquiao has a granite chin, so in a straight war, Corrales would walk away the victor.

Jose Luis Castillo would break Pacquiao down. Big body ****er, Pacquiao's body had already been proven to be weak. Pacquiao would need a JMM controversial decision to beat JLC. I don't see Pacquiao going far after taking shots to the body instead of the face. Start slowing down late rounds and then crumble from there on out.

Pacquiao wouldn't beat Genaro Hernandez either. That version of Pacquiao was too undisciplined, he would have been killed by the seasoned vet. You think the guy who beat Azumah Nelson would lose to a version of Pacquiao that got outboxed by Morales? No.

Good reasoning. I can respect that, and you may be right.