Do Adamek Warrent P4P Consideration?

[Crazylegs77]

yes and HBO please sign this guy for god sakes.

[Iceta Lives]

I don't think you can knock Adamek one bit for the way he fought that fight. Hell, Vitali used a lot of lateral movement on Arreola too. Both Vitali and Adamek boxed smart against him.

[Mikhnienko]

yes and HBO please sign this guy for god sakes.

Seriously after the Briggs fights and after the Cunn fight he doesn't get picked up. What the hell does he have to do.

His activity helps with p4p consideration imo.

[HaglerSteelChin]

I think he is among the top 10-15 P4P. He also has a chance in making history being the first fighter to win the three titles: LHW, Cruiser, and HW. Even guys like Holyfield and Spinks never accomplished that. He has a great chin but i think he has a better shot against Haye than either klitschko. But they are getting old so he may get them on a down side if he fights one of them next year.

[Stromprophet]

Not P4P yet. There are simply too many better fighters in front of him.

Not top 10 anyway. He's in the top 20 in my book.

[Spray_resistant]

When a title holder or champion from a lower division beats at the very least a top 10 guy in the next highest weight class they always should get P4P consideration over other guys who have been inactive at the very least.

This is the way I rank in my majical P4P fantasy ranking, which looks like dis.

Manny Pacquiao
Floyd Mayweather
Wladimir Klitschko
Sergio Martinez
Paul Williams
Shane Mosley
Tim Bradley
Tomasz Adamek
Chad Dawson
Chris John

I feel so naked now that everyone can see mine

[Stromprophet]

When a title holder or champion from a lower division beats at the very least a top 10 guy in the next highest weight class they always should get P4P consideration over other guys who have been inactive at the very least.

This is the way I rank in my majical P4P fantasy ranking, which looks like dis.

Manny Pacquiao
Floyd Mayweather
Wladimir Klitschko
Sergio Martinez
Paul Williams
Shane Mosley
Tim Bradley
Tomasz Adamek
Chad Dawson
Chris John

I feel so naked now that everyone can see mine

You have Chad ranked below him, despite the fact that he dominated Adamek. Don't talk about fighting recently, because you have Shane up there ahead of him and Shane hasn't fought in 14 months.

Adamek handily won this fight. But he was sloppy as heck. It wasn't a P4P performance. He didn't TKO Chris.

I actually agree with a lot of your list. Except I would have JMM on mine, and Wlady wouldn't be 3rd because he's not a better P4P fighter than Shane.

And I don't have Sergio on mine because Sergio has only beat 1 name fighter. I really do not understand all this Sergio love. Every fight he has is controversial. He didn't dominate Pavlik, if not for him cutting Pavlik in the 9th he loses that fight.

People are ranking him like he beat Paul Williams. He didn't.

You've got Israel Vazquez, Rafeal Marquez, Arthur Abraham, Miguel Cotto, etc, etc. Who all are ahead of Adamek without question, you might argue Sergio but not really, those guys *careers* make them P4P over Sergio.

[Spray_resistant]

You have Chad ranked below him, despite the fact that he dominated Adamek. Don't talk about fighting recently, because you have Shane up there ahead of him and Shane hasn't fought in 14 months.

Adamek handily won this fight. But he was sloppy as heck. It wasn't a P4P performance. He didn't TKO Chris.

I actually agree with a lot of your list. Except I would have JMM on mine, and Wlady wouldn't be 3rd because he's not a better P4P fighter than Shane.

And I don't have Sergio on mine because Sergio has only beat 1 name fighter. I really do not understand all this Sergio love. Every fight he has is controversial. He didn't dominate Pavlik, if not for him cutting Pavlik in the 9th he loses that fight.

People are ranking him like he beat Paul Williams. He didn't.

You've got Israel Vazquez, Rafeal Marquez, Arthur Abraham, Miguel Cotto, etc, etc. Who all are ahead of Adamek without question, you might argue Sergio but not really, those guys *careers* make them P4P over Sergio.

Its my rankings and I go by who I think won what fights and I had Sergio>>>PWill.

Also I am a fan of Dawson but he hasn't done much lately of note and when you compare its to Adamek's recent wins there is no comparison. His best win is still Adamek which wasn't a great win and now the man has totally eclipsed him.

If Dawson beat Cunningham forget about Arreola it would be his best win to date.

I can't ignore 9kos in the last 11wins in regards to Wlad, he is by far the most dominant champion in the world today.

[Motofan]

Has he done enough to be discussed for P4P status?

Nope. Not yet.