FAO for everybody who likes P4P list

[jrosales13]

If Adamek beats Arreola decisively. Would he be in the top 10 P4P discussion?

He was the WBC LHW champ and top 5 LHW, he was the lineal cruiserweight champ, and a win over Arreola would mean he just beat a top 10 HW. And, Adamek would possible be in the top 5 at HW. Which means he would be top 5 in 3 competed in that spanned 25+ pounds. And, his only lost was to a talented Chad Dawson who is most top 10 P4P list...

So would Adamek be in the top 10 discussion if he wins?

Vote and discuss....

[Doctor_Tenma]

I honestly don't know. I don't even pay attention to P4P lists anymore. I can atleast say that if Donaire is in it, then Adamek sure as hell deserves to be on it, especially with a win over Arreola.

[Clyde Barrow]

No, and screw p4p.

[Ekscape]

I wouldnt mind if they took Caballero or Donaire of the list for him if he beat Arreola (though Martinez probably should deserve it more)... but then at the end of the day you also gotta ask, "what the hell has Arreola done?" "Who has he beat of signficance?"... He wasn't even competative with Vitali

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

yes he should be consider

[street bully]

The p4p list has gone to ****. Fighters get taken off even with easy wins, guys like donair are on it frombeating one fighter in their whole career. Other lose one fight in handicap matches and drop multiple spots, it is stupi, really.

[El Rab]

if youre talking about the rings list its a joke. the list on here is better.

[jrosales13]

if youre talking about the rings list its a joke. the list on here is better.

I am talking about any list, I don't care who's....

I am not big on P4P because I think it is a mythical opinion. But, should Adamek if he beats Arreola. Should he be considered for the 10 P4P list. It could be BS or Ring or you personal list. Whatever...

[El Rab]

I am talking about any list, I don't care who's....

I am not big on P4P because I think it is a mythical opinion. But, should Adamek if he beats Arreola. Should he be considered for the 10 P4P list. It could be BS or Ring or you personal list. Whatever...

i wouldnt have too much of a problem i suppose if someone had in. if were going by p4p in the sense of if all the fighters were in the same class with all the same attributes and such i dunno if i personally can picture adamek in that select group.

[PH|L]

i voted no i fully expect Adamek to beat ARreola who is not very skilled and out of shape.