What if Question on Oscar Delahoya

[Imhotep]

Oscar fought alot of good quality opponents and Oscar lost some,won some,lost a few controversial decisions and won a few controversial decisions.What if Oscar had won all of them,where would you rank him in your all time p4p list.

[Swag Hustla]

Number one... Think of all the p4p kings he fought and lost to.

[Pullcounter]

Oscar fought alot of good quality opponents and Oscar lost some,won some,lost a few controversial decisions and won a few controversial decisions.What if Oscar had won all of them,where would you rank him in your all time p4p list.

if dlh won them all he'd be top 5 ATG at the least. I mean dlh fought a lot of great boxers.

[Khalid X]

Well Oscars resume would look like this

Wins over
ATG's
Floyd Mayweather
Manny Pacquiao
Felix Trinidad
Bernard Hopkins
Pernell Whitaker

HOF's
Julio Cesar Chavez
Shane Mosley

Great wins
Ike Quartey
OBa Carr
Rafael Ruelas

and also He would have faced Cotto and Hatton, so you could also add those two names to his resume as well.

I would say he would be top 5 and without actually breaking down everything, and going off the top of my dome, I would say that would be enough to land him in at #3 spot ATG behind Ali and Robinson.

[Khalid X]

As great as that list would be, I still feel Ali's resume and Robinson's resume might be better, which says alot.

[Toney Loc]

He could've been the greatest fighter ever, IMO.

[-Huey-]

He would have had an even bigger following, probably would have sold over 3 million PPV's everytime he fought. I would have considered him the best ever!

[Imhotep]

I would have considered Oscar to be the best p4p ever.