Assuming floyd beats shane, would you give him more credit than cotto?

[dibzvincent143]

I'D SAY HELL NO.

but i know it still depends on how floyd will win. i predict a SD though.
so i still chose cotto's win is better.

[Ravishing]

I'd give him credit for it, you have to.

Fighters from time to time lose to the best, it's apart of Boxing. We can't big up Shane in this fight and root for him, then just call him old if Floyd beats him (especially if it's close).

It'll be a much different fight all together than Mosley vs Cotto and I'm sure Mosley is going in with a different strategy than he had with Cotto.

[V.WEBB]

I'D SAY HELL NO.

but i know it still depends on how floyd will win. i predict a SD though.
so i still chose cotto's win is better.

Curious...are you a Manny fan?

[savorduhflavor]

Not more or less credit. The same credit. If Floyd beats Shane it will be one of the best wins of his career. No one should discredit it, just like no one should discredit Cotto's win over Shane.

[Jim Jeffries]

Well Cotto beat a more active, closer to prime version, so Floyd would have to put on a dominating performance in order to get more credit.

Floyd gets credit for winning either way though.

[dibzvincent143]

Curious...are you a Manny fan?

yes.
i am a 17 year old filipino, but i always bet on floyd whenever and whoever he fights.or will fight.except pacman.

[dibzvincent143]

Curious...are you a Manny fan?

yes.
i am a 17 year old filipino, but i always bet on floyd whenever and whoever he fights.or will fight.except pacman.

[JBell11]

I'd give props where it's due. SOOO...if FLoyd did beat Mosely, I'd give Floyd credit!

Now if you mean who deserves MORE credit that the other??? I'd say Cotto hands down deserves more credit that Floyd. Cotto is just more willing to fight, whether it will be a Malanagii, jennings, Mosely, Clottey, Pac. He literally fights whoever you put infront of him like a robot. Good bad or indifferent...that's his way. I bet if Arum said....fight WIlliams...I think Cotto will fight Williams.

Now...Floyd on the other hand...he's just been selective over the years. I was dissapointed in Floyd because of it awhile back...but I learned to respect Floyd and his talents.

[dibzvincent143]

Well Cotto beat a more active, closer to prime version, so Floyd would have to put on a dominating performance in order to get more credit.

Floyd gets credit for winning either way though.

yah!thats what i exactly mean.

[murmagic]

i didnt no 17 year olds could gamble