Rank these 3 fighters by Counter Punching Ability

[illmatickid]

James Toney

Pernell Whitaker

Floyd Mayweather


oh and plz state your reasons

[Heru]

1- Toney - smoothest transitions, seemed as if every time he made an opponent miss, he would come back with something soft or hard.
2- Mayweather
3- Whitaker

If you put it backwards it ranks them by best defense. I'll explain why later.

Whitaker
Mayweather
Toney

[o0P4PBOXING0o]

In terms of pure counterpunching id have to go with Toney, If you watch him when he was really on point in his prime he was a master at leaning over and coming back with the right hand. Sometimes he would double and triple it up aswell. The fight with Barkley shows this.

Pernell wasnt really like as much of a counter puncher as Toney or Floyd, He could do it but he relied more on his excellent defence and jab to win his fights.

Counter punching goes like this
1. Toney
2. Floyd
3. Pernell

But defence is the exact opposite with Pernell #1 followed by Floyd. Although they all had/have an excellent defence.

[illmatickid]

interesting stuff guys

[illmatickid]

^bump

and wat about roy.. if he was in the mix.. how would u guys rate em?

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Mayweather

Toney

Sweet Pea

[BigStereotype]

1. Toney
2. Floyd
3. Whitaker
4. Roy Jones

I think that Floyd's the best counterpuncher I seen, but Toney is so much bigger and heavier that it is just that much more impressive.

[F l i c k e r]

Mayweather

Toney

Sweet Pea

Co-sign......

[Kagami Taiga]

mayweather def. has the flashier counters. but i think toney is overall better and whitaker comes in at 3rd.

[Pullcounter]

whitaker

floyd

toney