Is Cotto overrated?

[Earl-Hickey]

I seen people saying he can beat Martinez.

now me personally, I just think it's two different levels of fighter.

I like Cotto, and he deserves props for fighting everyone, but I don't see him beating any true, elite fighters in there primes, much less a bigger one like martinez

[-GDS-]

If this were the past, you'd probably be red K'd into oblivion. I think that's a bit unfair to Cotto; in his prime he was a really good fighter, maybe not SRL beating, but still a good fighter. However, when he fights Berto later this year, I'd pick against him. But of course that's the Pac vs Cotto version. Who knows how he could bounce back with Steward.

[paulf]

NO chance he beats Martinez, man. Sergio will dance around him and mark him up.

He'll be lucky to get by Foreman.

[boxing fanatic]

cotto overrated

no i dont think he is overated he is a very good fighter with good boxing skills we saw that against mosley its just that he has lost 2 of 3 big fights to margarito to pacqiuao and barely beat mosley so you know were does he stand with me a very good fighter but not great.

[DR.ORGYY]

no way man cotto is elite....

[Dick Buffman]

depends how you rate him.

if you say he's a great fighter , then you are.

if you say he's a HOF level good fighter , then you aren't.

[PureBoxer]

Martinez would knock Cotto out under 5 rounds.