Miguel Cotto Or Joe Calzaghe. Who's Greater And Why?

[Southpaw Great]

Well, who do you rank as the greater fighter at thsi moment in time?

[PureBoxer]

Calzaghe is a much better boxer with a better chin.

[-EX-]

Calzaghe........neither have beaten any elite prime fighters tho

I like Cotto's opposition way better tho...

And Cotto isn't done yet...

[FloydTBE]

Cotto never ducked or dodges nodbody, fought best out there in his division.

[The_Demon]

calzaghe no doubt

that said cotto is still active,although i think he will not be half the fighter he once was due to the beatings he has taken and his clear lack of staminia

[rskumm21]

Cotto's resume is better than Calzaghe, no one can argue that. Maybe if he hadn't fought such stiff competition, he'd be undefeated as well...

[SoldierWarrior]

**** your ****ty topic, I like both boxers equally and will not answer this horrible question. Both are great thats whats up and thats how I'll answer it. And also this topic creator has a habbit of bad-mouthing Calzaghe, he even had one ****ty ass poll asking who is the most boring fighter out of these and he had Calzaghe as an option. Topic creator is clearly a Calzaghe hater, he can go **** himself.

[ModernTalking]

Well, who do you rank as the greater fighter at thsi moment in time?

Whether people like it or not Calzaghe will be a legend.

[Mr. Invincible]

Calzaghe at this point. By a mile. The reason why is simple. He had way more defenses, never lost to a one dimentional slugger like Margacheato and had way more fights, even if was mostly against softer competition.

[jrosales13]

Calzaghe is greater.