Could JMM beat a 135 Pound Prime Floyd?

[BoxerDood]

Floyd would dominate him over 12. It would just be a faster paced version of their fight at WW, possibly with more knockdowns.

[AKATheMack]

Cmon man we about to play this game? He was gone since he last fought Hatton in 2007. He wanted to shake off ring rust. Hes not allowed tune ups now? Says who?

Cotto can fight Urkal, Gomez and Jennings and Marg can fight Golden Johnson but Floyd cant take a tune up to get back in the swing of things.

Shane is coming off of a similar layoff at 38yrs of age and chooses to fight the best fighter on the planet. I apologize if you cant see why I think Floyd may be a bit cowardly. And to answer your question NO I dont believe any fighter should be allowed a tune up on PPV, if you want that paycheck earn it.

[pasawayako]

If anyone watched the Mayweather/Marquez fight it is obvious that Marquez would have been outclassed by Mayweather at any weight.

floyd's size and weight help him win the fight, just look at funeka vs guzman.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Shane is coming off of a similar layoff at 38yrs of age and chooses to fight the best fighter on the planet. I apologize if you cant see why I think Floyd may be a bit cowardly. And to answer your question NO I dont believe any fighter should be allowed a tune up on PPV, if you want that paycheck earn it.

Shane is coming off a layoff and needs the payday that Floyd brings. Floyd made over 20 Mil fighting JMM. Shane literally couldnt afford a tune up and its not like Shanes layoff was planned anyway. If that earthquake doesnt happens he wouldve fought Berto by now.

[xcaret v3]

Cmon man we about to play this game? He was gone since he last fought Hatton in 2007. He wanted to shake off ring rust. Hes not allowed tune ups now? Says who?

Cotto can fight Urkal, Gomez and Jennings and Marg can fight Golden Johnson but Floyd cant take a tune up to get back in the swing of things.

Cotto fought natural welterweights, are you gonna tell me floyd did the same ****?


come on idiot say it.

[Blubba]

Its no fantasy that Floyd outclassed Marquez easily whereas Pac fought him twice & barely won once. Then chose to fight David Diaz instead of fighting Marquez again.

lets not play this game

It's no fantasy that Pacquiao outclassed hatton in two rounds and took out oscar in only 8, sent him into retirement, which floyd needed 10 rounds on hatton and a feeble 12 round SD on Oscar. Then retired himself instead of rematching oscar.

[AKATheMack]

Shane is coming off a layoff and needs the payday that Floyd brings. Floyd made over 20 Mil fighting JMM. Shane literally couldnt afford a tune up and its not like Shanes layoff was planned anyway. If that earthquake doesnt happens he wouldve fought Berto by now.

After a 1yr layoff WW Berto is still a much more legitimate opponent than a LW Marquez. I also don't think it only comes down to money. Mosley has shown a willingness to test himself throughout his career where Floyd has not.

[KILLA RIGHT]

Floyd wins 8 4 on a dominant performance

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

After a 1yr layoff WW Berto is still a much more legitimate opponent than a LW Marquez. I also don't think it only comes down to money. Mosley has shown a willingness to test himself throughout his career where Floyd has not.

Im at the point right now to where I just dont give a damn. **** Marquez. It was a tune up and nothing more you dont see people hyping that win.

Hes fighting Mosley now. The best WW in the world and the P4P Number 3.

[xcaret v3]

135 dlh beats a 135 floyd any time...