Is Amir Khan Under-Rated?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Hard Boiled
    Undisputed Champion
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Mar 2010
    • 1462
    • 118
    • 0
    • 7,901

    #1

    Is Amir Khan Under-Rated?

    I have seen a thread saying that Khan is over-rated but I truely believe that he is grossly under-rated here are my reasons why:

    1. At the age of just 17 he fought the lengendary three time olympic gold medalist Mario Kindelan who as an amatuer defeated both Felix Trinidad and Miguel Cotto. Khan later beat Mario Kindelan in a rematch which was his last fight as an amatuer. Khan became the youngest Olympic medalist for UK since 1952 when he won the Silver.

    2.His main trainer was Oliver Harrison who was a world champion kickboxer and didnt teach him much defence. Now he has Freddie Roach the best trainer in the world. I doubt Freddie Roach would have taken him on if he thought he was talentless. He rejected the offer to work with Ricky Hatton and Kevin Mitchell.

    3. He is the youngest world champion in British boxing history, Most boxers dont turn professional until 22, Amir Khan became world champion at 22. I believe he is third youngest in British history.

    4. He trains and spars with Manny Pacquio, You cant get better experience and sparring than the best P4P in the world.

    5.He has moved up in weight from lightweight where he struggled to make weight and was weight drained and not so great punch resistence. He was top heavy and had limited leg muscle. Now he is a much more rounded fighter, Larger calf and thigh muscles have helped his punch resistence. His conditioning is top notch thanks to Alex Arizza.

    6. He has faced much tougher opposition at a younger age than even the greats like Hatton, Beating a Barrera, Gomez, Kotelnik, Salita. Hatton for example was fighting journeymen at the age of 22 and did not have a world title.

    7. Its difficult for him to get fights, Marquez is too scared to fight Khan, Maidana thinks its safer to fight Timothy Bradley. Ortiz would rather fight a fading Nate Campbell. Malignaggi agreed to the fight for a pay-day, He gets $250,000 just for turning up win or loose.

    8.His popularity in Britian is the cause of much envy, grievance, dislike, Xenophobia and racism. He is Pakistani-British and Britian does not treat its ********** with respect like ********** in the USA ie Barak *****. Khan even said himself "If I were white I would be a super-star in the UK". To deny that Khan faces racism in the UK is to be either niave or duplicitous.

    9.He has defeated all his opponents bar Bredis Prescott in a lopsided fashion, There is no fight of his that you can really say Khan struggled. Fact no British boxer has been able to defeat Khan or come close.

    10.The critics say he has a "Glass jaw" because he was suffered a fluke KO by an opponent who at the time had a 90% KO ratio. Since moving up in weight he has not struggled with taking hard shots, He hasnt been on the canvas since moving up in weight. Also he took more than one flush shot by Prescott and got up the first time and tried the second time, Even if the critics continue repeating this mantra of "glass jaw" they can not question his heart.

    For these reasons I believe that AK is grossly under-rated. I would like you to share your opinions but please keep it respectful and refrain from bad language.

    Best Regards.
    Last edited by Hard Boiled; 04-11-2010, 09:30 AM.
  • - v e t -
    are you a badfish too?
    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
    • Aug 2009
    • 14891
    • 1,202
    • 1,329
    • 27,883

    #2
    IF by underrated you mean overrated, then yes

    Comment

    • B.U.R.N.E.R
      ~NSB Legend 2005-2015~
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • Feb 2010
      • 30197
      • 1,346
      • 400
      • 47,475

      #3
      He hasnt accomplished **** so how can he be underrated?

      Comment

      • BROOKLYN CESAR
        Undisputed Champion
        • May 2007
        • 2326
        • 81
        • 2
        • 8,850

        #4
        No he is not under rated its the other way round sorry champ!!!

        Comment

        • flexxx145
          Banned
          • Dec 2009
          • 2085
          • 87
          • 106
          • 2,291

          #5
          "Its difficult for him to get fights, Marquez is too scared to fight Khan, Maidana thinks its safer to fight Timothy Bradley. Ortiz would rather fight a fading Nate Campbell. Malignaggi agreed to the fight for a pay-day, He gets $250,000 just for turning up win or loose."

          So Bradley, Marquez, Ortiz, Alexander, basically every big name at 140lb's is supposed to be ducking Amir Khan according to you LOL! Wow the Khan fans are starting to get worse than *******s.

          Comment

          • hookoutofhell
            Undisputed Champion
            Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
            • Dec 2007
            • 2752
            • 82
            • 52
            • 9,101

            #6
            Originally posted by Hard Boiled
            I have seen a thread saying that Khan is over-rated but I truely believe that he is grossly under-rated here are my reasons why:

            1. At the age of just 17 he fought the lengendary three time olympic gold medalist Mario Kindelan who as an amatuer defeated both Felix Trinidad and Miguel Cotto. Khan later beat Mario Kindelan in a rematch which was his last fight as an amatuer. Khan became the youngest Olympic medalist for UK since 1952 when he won the Silver.

            2.His main trainer was Oliver Harrison who was a world champion kickboxer and didnt teach him much defence. Now he has Freddie Roach the best trainer in the world. I doubt Freddie Roach would have taken him on if he thought he was talentless. He rejected the offer to work with Ricky Hatton and Kevin Mitchell.

            3. He is the youngest world champion in British boxing history, Most boxers dont turn professional until 22, Amir Khan became world champion at 22. I believe he is third youngest in British history.

            4. He trains and spars with Manny Pacquio, You cant get better experience and sparring than the best P4P in the world.

            5.He has moved up in weight from lightweight where he struggled to make weight and was weight drained and not so great punch resistence. He was top heavy and had limited leg muscle. Now he is a much more rounded fighter, Larger calf and thigh muscles have helped his punch resistence. His conditioning is top notch thanks to Alex Arizza.

            6. He has faced much tougher opposition at a younger age than even the greats like Hatton, Beating a Barrera, Gomez, Kotelnik, Salita. Hatton for example was fighting journeymen at the age of 22 and did not have a world title.

            7. Its difficult for him to get fights, Marquez is too scared to fight Khan, Maidana thinks its safer to fight Timothy Bradley. Ortiz would rather fight a fading Nate Campbell. Malignaggi agreed to the fight for a pay-day, He gets $250,000 just for turning up win or loose.

            8.His popularity in Britian is the cause of much envy, grievance, dislike, Xenophobia and racism. He is Pakistani-British and Britian does not treat its ********** with respect like ********** in the USA ie Barak *****. Khan even said himself "If I were white I would be a super-star in the UK". To deny that Khan faces racism in the UK is to be either niave or duplicitous.

            9.He has defeated all his opponents bar Bredis Prescott in a lopsided fashion, There is no fight of his that you can really say Khan struggled. Fact no British boxer has been able to defeat Khan or come close.

            10.The critics say he has a "Glass jaw" because he was suffered a fluke KO by an opponent who at the time had a 90% KO ratio. Since moving up in weight he has not struggled with taking hard shots, He hasnt been on the canvas since moving up in weight. Also he took more than one flush shot by Prescott and got up the first time and tried the second time, Even if the critics continue repeating this mantra of "glass jaw" they can not question his heart.

            For these reasons I believe that AK is grossly under-rated. I would like you to share your opinions but please keep it respectful and refrain from bad language.

            Best Regards.
            1) yes thats true but khan has style that is suited to the am game.

            2) granted thats true enough

            3) yeah hes a got a world title but hes far from a championship level fighter. he took on a fight against the weakest title holder in the division

            4) yes, your right he does spar and train pacman with pacman and he does quite well but i think khans style means that he is more suited to boxing with headgear and protection

            5) yes he does have thicker legs but they haven't really been tested at 140 have they. when he takes a flush punch from a 140lb fighter (devon alexander, bradders, maidana etc) then we can say his chin is fine. his conditioing is not as good as some might like to believe neither, he was huffing and puffing in the kotelnik fight

            6) now you're clutching at straws; barrerra was a shot fighter, gomez had very little left in the tank but managed to deck khan, salita was a clever match up as they knew he would be drained. kotelnik is his best win.

            you make some good points about his coach not being a real boxing coach and a few others but on the whole he is over rated.

            couldn't be bothered with the rest.....

            Comment

            • -Mustang-
              El Chapo Guzman
              Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
              • Jan 2008
              • 4224
              • 608
              • 520
              • 14,669

              #7

              Comment

              • rod_serrs
                Contender
                Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
                • Sep 2008
                • 476
                • 11
                • 1
                • 6,759

                #8
                Your 'facts' don't indicate that he's underrated. Most have no relevance to his in ring performances. Look he's not underrated because he hasn't accomplished much to warrant the label, but at the same time he's not overrated either because most people don't believe his supposed greatness yet. He looks like a solid fighter that is getting better with proper training that suffered a hiccup in his career that he wasn't supposed to. Now when Malignaggi beats him, then you will hear him being called overrated.

                Comment

                • d0n
                  Contender
                  Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
                  • Jul 2009
                  • 228
                  • 3
                  • 0
                  • 6,544

                  #9
                  Nice thread. Good facts. I think he is yet to achieve alot, don't know whether he is under rated though, but definitely NOT overrated.

                  Comment

                  • MUNG
                    Death Dealer
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • May 2009
                    • 4183
                    • 438
                    • 79
                    • 31,567

                    #10
                    I think hes about right, most people are waiting to see if he can be competitive at 140 and then he will be rated

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP