These are facts....shane is old

[STRUGG]

......INACTIVE.........and past prime.........is he still a good opponent ???.........yes................should floyd get credit for fighting him = some credit....................

[AllEyesOpen]

Old; yes

inactive; yes

shot; no

past his prime; not by much

better opponent the Clottey; no doubt.

[Shattered Jaw]

Old; yes

inactive; yes

shot; no

past his prime; not by much

better opponent the Clottey; no doubt.

LOL! Got to love Floyd fans.

[GTL]

i really dont think hes a better opponent than clottey. call me crazy, but i think if they fought itd be a close fight..

that being said, shane is old, and this fight will be a boring UD for floyd.. it will look like the marquez fight. just a lil uglier.. shane might try to get in on the inside, but hes still going to get potshotted to a loss..

[AllEyesOpen]

LOL! Got to love Floyd fans.

it's Clottey own fault for being so unwilling to fight to win.

[2501]

So would these facts still apply if it was Pacquiao facing Shane?

[War Dinamita]

The best WW? Yes.

The champ at WW? Yes.

The best available opponent at the time? Yes.

An ATG? Yes.

The current #3 p4p? Yes.

The same guy Manny ducked a few months ago because he's too good? Yeah, that's him.

[STRUGG]

Old; yes

inactive; yes

shot; no

past his prime; not by much

better opponent the Clottey; no doubt.

yes he is......he was being outboxed by mayorga........better opponent than clottey i agree..........but Cotto was a hell lot better opponent than fat old SFW ATG JMM

[CarlosG815]

Shane Mosley is a great fighter.

The #1 Welterweight.

One of the greatest WW's of all time.

Destroyed Margarito not too long ago.

A man who obviously has a lesser "boxing age" than many boxers are at when their real age is 35.

Sugar Shane is THE BEST fight for Manny or Floyd right now. He is better than anybody else that they can fight.

TBH if Manny does not fight Floyd, then Shane is the only other fight that matters, nobody else.

Manny will go and fight guys like Margarito, Cotto 2, etc.. Shane is better than both of them.

Those are facts.

[STRUGG]

So would these facts still apply if it was Pacquiao facing Shane?

yep....................but the thing is theyll be trading punches...........i still think mosley got the chin and power to be very dangerous for pacs style,................