Better trainer: Floyd Sr. or Roger?

[Eaner0919]

Roger is one of the most underrated trainers in the game.

agreed and the reclamation job he did with Lock is kind of proof. Lock is really nothing special yet he keeps upsetting guys who were supposed to use him as a stepping stone

also Roger has Jesse Vargas who is an undefeated prospect and making a bit of a name for himself also

Sr IMO is known more for screwing with fighter's styles and messing them up

Bojado
Mares
Guzman
Dawson
DLH

all never really benefitted from what Sr knows

[DIB42]

Jeff Mayweather, because you can understand the words coming out of his mouth without subtitles.

I think Jeff is probably the secret ingrediant.

[tredh]

agreed and the reclamation job he did with Lock is kind of proof. Lock is really nothing special yet he keeps upsetting guys who were supposed to use him as a stepping stone

also Roger has Jesse Vargas who is an undefeated prospect and making a bit of a name for himself also

Sr IMO is known more for screwing with fighter's styles and messing them up

Bojado
Mares
Guzman
Dawson
DLH

all never really benefitted from what Sr knows

I gotta disagree with you on Sr. messing fighters styles up. I feel I actually saw improvement in De la Hoya when he was with Sr. I believe that it was Joan Guzman(That is Guzman you talking about?) who used to be with Sr. that dude has regressed I have not been liking his performances at all. Guzman can fight but he needs someone to keep him on track. Chad Dawson has not regressed and he has not improved greatly either.

People have to realize none of Sr's fighters who have left have said or I haven't heard them say anything negative about Sr. training ability and what he teaches them. They have all said they have problems with his ATTITUDE and that is believable. Night and day difference from being a bad trainer and having a bad attitude. **** PBF left his father alone because of his attitude not his training ablilites.

[Eaner0919]

I gotta disagree with you on Sr. messing fighters styles up. I feel I actually saw improvement in De la Hoya when he was with Sr.

nope

Sr basically took away DLH's one shining aspect he brought with him up to 147, the left hook. He had him not planting and driving through his punches he had him playing defense and DLH was horrible at it.

I believe that it was Joan Guzman(That is Guzman you talking about?) who used to be with Sr. that dude has regressed I have not been liking his performances at all. Guzman can fight but he needs someone to keep him on track.

Chad Dawson has not regressed and he has not improved greatly either.

during his stint with Floyd Dawson looked bad IMO and has looked much much better under Eddie Mustafa

People have to realize none of Sr's fighters who have left have said or I haven't heard them say anything negative about Sr. training ability and what he teaches them.

wrong

Mares told me when he came back from Sr that he didn't feel comfortable and didn't really like the style.

Bojado the same thing.

They have all said they have problems with his ATTITUDE and that is believable. Night and day difference from being a bad trainer and having a bad attitude. **** PBF left his father alone because of his attitude not his training ablilites.

hmm the only person who didn't like his attitude is seemingly Hatton

[tredh]

nope

Sr basically took away DLH's one shining aspect he brought with him up to 147, the left hook. He had him not planting and driving through his punches he had him playing defense and DLH was horrible at it.





during his stint with Floyd Dawson looked bad IMO and has looked much much better under Eddie Mustafa



wrong

Mares told me when he came back from Sr that he didn't feel comfortable and didn't really like the style.

Bojado the same thing.


hmm the only person who didn't like his attitude is seemingly Hatton

We can agree to disagree but Sr. never took the left hook away from De la Hoya he had De la Hoya using his right hand more which was needed IMO.

I can't be wrong if I said "I didn't hear any fighters" and you said the dude came back and told "YOU" meaning I didn't hear it. Never said it wasn't said.
Dawson didn't like Sr. attitude either.

[Eaner0919]

ok bro agree to disagree but Mares and Bojado both have told me his style didn't fit them

[ussy]

Dont give a damn about thread topic on the real who the F**K is that chick?????

is anyone gonna answer this poor guys question? *holds breath*

[Irish Hitman]

Floyd Snr has a better resume of top name fighters-Hatton and De Le Hoya
but
Roger is a better trainer- Floyd Jnr

[DIB42]

is anyone gonna answer this poor guys question? *holds breath*

there was a link under the picture...
he can figure it out from there