Who beat Roy Jones easier, Calzaghe or Hopkins?

[Idgas]

Danny Green

and boom. there it is hahah.

[infamous larryx]

antonio tarver

[infamous larryx]

tarver ko'd prime roy in 2

[Mr. Invincible]

Yes, It had to be done.

The answer is so obvious that the thread is a complete waste of time. Congratulations.

[IIG]

I had Hopkins winning the fight 117-110, but he was not impressive. He was in a fight with a guy that refused to throw punches. Calzaghe put on a clinic and mocked Jones the whole duration of the fight. I can never watch that fight again.

[Mr. Invincible]

tarver ko'd prime roy in 2

As evident in the first fight with Tarver, Roy was no longr prime after moving down from heavyweight.

[infamous larryx]

As evident in the first fight with Tarver, Roy was no longr prime after moving down from heavyweight.

tarver beat the best version of roy..hense he gets all the credit

[Siggy]

no wins over RJJ post glen johnson matter.
he's been shot for over 5 yrs.
a win over a shot fighter is a win over a shot fighter.

[Mr. Invincible]

tarver beat the best version of roy..hense he gets all the credit

Out of his losses, I tend to agree but you said 'prime Roy' and I beg to differ. That's all.

Nobody that has officially beat Roy Jones would have came close in his prime.

[The Hammer]

Joe Calzaghe won 11 rounds, dominated 10 of those rounds, busted up Jones face, and didn't need to put on acts to exaggerate the effects of fouls.

And Jones seemed somewhat faster and more fluid in his movements in the Calzaghe fight, he was past-prime but not shot at that time. However, he looked awful (old and 100% shot) last night.