If Abraham KO'd Mayweather and Mosley.....

[Mr. Philadel]

lets just say Abe had stayed at 160 and held all the straps.....lets say Floyd and Shane BOTH moved up to challenge him and BOTH got stopped......would you give Abraham credit for the wins or would you discredit his wins because Shane and Floyd were WW's?!?.....just wanna know ......a simple yes or no would be cool and if you feel like raining some knowledge, be my guest!!

poll on the way

[BrooklynBomber]

I would give him some credit, because while Abe is a bigger guy, he is not that much bigger then either Mosley(who I think is the same height or even a little taller) or Mayweather

[krispy kreme]

Yes, does this have to do with Hopkins btw? lol.

[Hi-Dro]

yes i would give him credit

i doubt floyd would fight him though and take the risk

shane on the other hand welcomes all challenges

[Mr. Philadel]

Yes, does this have to do with Hopkins btw? lol.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Not really.

Hes a 168 Pounder.

[krispy kreme]

Every month someone makes a thread discrediting Hopkins, you can do that **** to so many fighters who had their opponent move up in weight.

[disolly]

if they were proven middleweights, if they came up now and fought him, at 160 then NO. I don't give credit to Floyd for beating a much smaller Marquez. Just cause you are taller then a guy does not make you bigger. AA is a lot thicker then both guys. I won't give much credit to Pavlik if he beats Martinez or Williams, cause neither have proved to be top middleweights.

[damned1974]

lets just say Abe had stayed at 160 and held all the straps.....lets say Floyd and Shane BOTH moved up to challenge him and BOTH got stopped......would you give Abraham credit for the wins or would you discredit his wins because Shane and Floyd were WW's?!?.....just wanna know ......a simple yes or no would be cool and if you feel like raining some knowledge, be my guest!!

poll on the way

this is ironic,because anyone who doesn't give Floyd credit for beating Marquez should really wonder why they would give Abraham credit for beating these two boxers who are 3 divisions smaller than him...really bizarre poll imo...

[damned1974]

if they were proven middleweights, if they came up now and fought him, at 160 then NO. I don't give credit to Floyd for beating a much smaller Marquez. Just cause you are taller then a guy does not make you bigger. AA is a lot thicker then both guys. I won't give much credit to Pavlik if he beats Martinez or Williams, cause neither have proved to be top middleweights.

Out of curiosity,who would Pavlik have to beat to get credit from you? You do realize that ATM there really aren't any top brilliant MW fighters at the moment....unless you count Sturm.
I actually believe Martinez is a nightmare style-wise for Pavlik as opposed to Paul Williams..
Kelly is in the bad predicament of being in a weak weight division...similar to the heavy weight division, where there are blown up cruiser weights fighting as HW's just to be involved in more lucrative match-ups.