If Mayweather KO's Mosley, does he deserve P4P #1?

[Mighty_Windir]

No, Pacquiao is #1, he has to beat him.

In fact I'd go as far to say Clottey could have gave hell to SSM.

[Shazam!]

Just for the record I don't think Mayweather with KO Mosley. But stranger things have happened.

[flexxx145]

No, Pacquiao is #1, he has to beat him.

In fact I'd go as far to say Clottey could have gave hell to SSM.

some peoples children lol!

[gqjohnb]

I'm a Pac fan more than a Mayweather fan, but for this I would vote yes. What do you think?

If you accept that a KO of Mosley is superior to a Decision over Clottey, then would a Mayweather KO of Mosley be deserving of P4P #1 Status? Remember, he's still undefeated...

I don't see that happening but yeah of course he does. I think a convincing UD over Mosley makes him P4P but thats just me I guess. Like I've said before I would be very shocked if ANYONE KO's shane mosley and they would get monster props from me.

[r.burgundy]

definitely.he doesnt even need a k.o

[renren40]

****kkk no floyd chicken **** don't deserve the p4p crown!!!

Plus that is a big IF.

There is no way Floyd will KO Mosley.

[FLY TY]

mayweather has to beat manny, or vice-versa, for their to be a true #1 p4p.


right now, it's based on who ppl like.

[Soundtraveler]

Hmmm let's see, Mosley has a ROCK for a chin and Mayweather has FEATHERS in his fist -- NOPE, sorry, but there is NO WAY Mayweather KO's Mosley. In fact I predict that Mosley will BEAT Mayweather.

The REAL fight is Mosley vs Pacman - now THAT will be a war, not a track meet like Mayweather vs Pacman would be....

[incredible]

I'm a Pac fan more than a Mayweather fan, but for this I would vote yes. What do you think?

If you accept that a KO of Mosley is superior to a Decision over Clottey, then would a Mayweather KO of Mosley be deserving of P4P #1 Status? Remember, he's still undefeated...

NO, No, and No! You have to beat the man to be the man. For as good a fighter as Mosely is...which he is good...he is not pound4pound best fighter in the world at this moment. That title belongs to Pacquiao, and order for mayweather to claim that title...he has to beat Pacquiao.