My current Heavyweight Top 10

[Double]

I pretty much agree with this list

A wise man, he is (damn they got me talkin' that yoda isht)

[!! Mr. Soprano]

We could go all day about this one.. But the first post has the worst list I've ever seen.

This is like Paper/Rock/Scissors..
Each HW has a chance of loosing.. But their legends will be built based on who they fight and how well they can avoid their threats.

e.g.
1) I think Vitali's top competition is: Rahman, Brewster, & Peter. No one else in the division possesses any threat.
2) Toney's threats are: W. Klitschko, V. Klitschko, Byrd, Rahman, Peter - who has a punchers chance and posesses a threat to anyone!
3) Byrd's Threats are: W. Klitschko, V. Klitschko, Toney, Peter, Brewster
4) Brewster.. : Byrd, Toney, V. Klitschko, Peter, Brock, W. Klitchko - outcome of a rematch might be different, Tyson, Tua
etc...

[guru]

as far as wins, i dont think they're is much difference in the quality of opponents ruiz/byrd/vk have beaten... rahman, fres, golota, sanders, donald, KJ, williams, mccline, old holyfield are all about the same...

[Michael Wittmann]

russian arm/veinbum,

youre the worst troll ever!

post a picture of your warty hooknoose, pleease!!

[paul750]

1. Vitali Klitschko
2. Chris Byrd
3. Wladimir Klitschko
4. James Toney
5. Hasim Rahman
6. Samuel Peter
7. Calvin Brock
8. Juan Carlos Gomez
9. Luan Krasniqi
10.Lamon Brewster

[Mr. Ryan]

1. Vitali Klitschko, Say what you want, no one can beat him right now.
2. Chris Byrd, Even though he's been struggling with B level opposition, the pool is kinda shallow.
3. James Toney, Positive test or no, steroids played no factor in him whipping Ruiz.
4. Lamon Brewster, Surpasses Ruiz based on the comparisons between their 2 experiences with Golata.
5. John Ruiz, What can I say, he's still around.
6. Hasim Rahman, Rejuvenated and hungry, he's surprising me by going up against the best in Klitschko.
7. Monte Barrett, this guy can fight!
8. Samuel Peter, the biggest puncher in the division. Has the most potential at 24.
9. Wladmir Klitschko, weak chin as it is, still has the skills and power to win his share.
10. Calvin Brock, I'm not quite sold on him, but he did beat McCline.

[splittingatoms]

even though i think that the division is weak my list goes like this

1 vitali (still think he is king bum)
2 byrd (should have him number 1 cuz he does hold a W over vit)
3 toney (should still have the belt)
4 wlad (could be the savior of the HW)
5 brewster (reason he is under wlad, cuz he didnt beat wlad
wlad beat himself)
6 rahman (did KO lewis and if ruiz wouldnt have danced with
him,he would have beaten ruiz)
7 Barrett (guy has skills just has to prove them)
8 peter (has great potential and looks to be a future champ)
9 tyson (guy still has power and if he could get his head out
of his ass he could make a run for one of the titles)
10 ruiz (worst one outta of the bunch.but have to put him in
top 10 because he did put the granite chinned holy on
the canvas)

[leff]

1. Vitali Klitschko, Say what you want, no one can beat him right now.
2. Chris Byrd, Even though he's been struggling with B level opposition, the pool is kinda shallow.
3. James Toney, Positive test or no, steroids played no factor in him whipping Ruiz.
4. Lamon Brewster, Surpasses Ruiz based on the comparisons between their 2 experiences with Golata.
5. John Ruiz, What can I say, he's still around.
6. Hasim Rahman, Rejuvenated and hungry, he's surprising me by going up against the best in Klitschko.
7. Monte Barrett, this guy can fight!
8. Samuel Peter, the biggest puncher in the division. Has the most potential at 24.
9. Wladmir Klitschko, weak chin as it is, still has the skills and power to win his share.
10. Calvin Brock, I'm not quite sold on him, but he did beat McCline.

NOthing to add, this guy know his stuff.

[NiGe2011]

(1) Vitali Klitschko -- not to beat a dead horse, but he is probably the most consistent guy here and has done nothing but KO people of late.
(2) Chris Byrd -- might be slowing down a little, but that has made for a more entertaining style and he is still winning.
(3) John Ruiz -- the fight with Toney is a no-contest, so I cannot take it into account- and not counting that, he is a champ and has taken care of business.
(4) Lamon Brewster -- KO of Golota and Wladimir gets him here, will operate under the assumption that the Brewster who fought Meehan is not the one who is fighting now.
(5) Hasim Rahman -- Is consistently beating the less talented heavyweights he has fought in impressive fashion. Barrett will be the first real test.
(6) James Toney -- since I am not counting Ruiz, Toney has only really beaten an aged Evander Holyfield and the completely unimpressive Rydell Booker. Still has the potential to move up though.
(7) Samuel Peter -- Like Rahman has been fighting some sturdy but less talented heavyweights, but still has looked scary doing it. Will not move up until he wins a big fight.
(8) Monte Barrett -- This guy does a number on prospects, pushing Mesi to the brink and beating Guinn and Beck. But then again, who doesnt beat Guinn these days?
(9) Calvin Brock -- the other undefeated heavyweight hope, the 'Boxing Banker' has not been all htat exciting, but is winning and the win over Mcline is the biggest victory to date from these prospects.
(10) Wladimir Klitschko -- the lesser of the Klitschko brothers still needs a convincing win over a solid heavyweight. But has posted wins in both his fights since losing to Brewster. Just barely gets him on the list.

[Enayze]

10. Monte Barrett (skilled, true fighter when focussed)
9. Vitali Klitschko (in my opinion, one of the most overrated boxers ever)
8. David Tua (hope he fights more often, he is real good I believe)
7. Samuel Peter (not experienced yet, but will be successful I think)
6. James Toney (difficult to judge because of his use of steroids)
5. Chris Byrd (If only he punched a little harder)
4. Hasim Rahman (a lot more than a one-hit-wonder)
3. John Ruiz (Very underrated in my honest view)
2. Lamon Brewster (Not only since he beat up Golota)
1. Mike Tyson (You may doubt he is the best, you shall see soon)

That list was excellent!!!!










If your mentally handicaped


Seriously bro, thats some of the largest crap I have ever seen. Wladimir Klitschko has the most potential out of all those heavyweights how come he's not no.1? Not to mention he beat Barret, Byrd, and Mc'Cline?