Mayweather vs Casamayor at 135 Prime 4 Prime: Who wins?

[BoxerDood]

This is a fight I always wanted to see. Their styles would mix perfectly and it would be a very competitive fight. Who do you think would take it?

[savorduhflavor]

That's honestly, in my opinion, as tough of a fight as Floyd would have had coming up.

I still think Floyd would have figured him out, but it would have been a very, very interesting fight.

[javelin_fangs]

This is a fight I always wanted to see. Their styles would mix perfectly and it would be a very competitive fight. Who do you think would take it?

First, I doubt it would have been competitive. Mayweather is better at everything that Casamayor was good at (see: JMM). Second, Casamayor had an offer of $1 mil to fight Mayweather back in 2002 on about 6 weeks notice and turned it down. He knew what was going to happen.

[F l i c k e r]

First, I doubt it would have been competitive. Mayweather is better at everything that Casamayor was good at (see: JMM). Second, Casamayor had an offer of $1 mil to fight Mayweather back in 2002 on about 6 weeks notice and turned it down. He knew what was going to happen.

Hell yeah he did. Casamayor would have got ****d by Mayweather. A systematic beatdown in there against Mayweather.

[Doctor_Tenma]

That's honestly, in my opinion, as tough of a fight as Floyd would have had coming up.

I still think Floyd would have figured him out, but it would have been a very, very interesting fight.

Agree, I'd give Casamayor a good chance.

[Left Banned Tua]

casa of course.

everyone knows this.

[mazdaru]

floyd by way of punishing casa

[Left Banned Tua]

guys who would have beat mayweather had floyd manned up and fought them:

1. kostya tszyu
2. manny pacquiao
3. joel casamayor
4. acelino freitas
5. antonio margarito
6. miguel cotto
7. paul williams
8. paul spadafora
9. steve johnston
10. steve forbes

[Jamel H]

casa of course.

everyone knows this.

And your 100% sure of that?

[Suckmedry]

guys who would have beat mayweather had floyd manned up and fought them:

1. kostya tszyu
2. manny pacquiao
3. joel casamayor
4. acelino freitas
5. antonio margarito
6. miguel cotto
7. paul williams
8. paul spadafora
9. steve johnston
10. steve forbes

I would give legit chances to Kostya, Pacquiao, Cotto, Williams and thats it.

The Spadafora thing is based on a sparring session 10 years ago when Floyd was clearly unfit and not in training for a fight, and Spadafora was.