If Clottey beats Pac...

[El Chicano]

big cotto fan here but im pretty sure clottey gives pac a much tougher fight then cotto did and in a rematch against miguel i would probably favor joshua i just dont think cotto is the same fighter mentally since the margs loss.

I'd favor Clottey in a rematch with Miguel also, especially after the Manny beatdown. I think the Clottey-Cotto rematch should happen regardless of the outcome this Saturday night... There is unfinished business there.

[Pullcounter]

I'd favor Clottey in a rematch with Miguel also, especially after the Manny beatdown. I think the Clottey-Cotto rematch should happen regardless of the outcome this Saturday night... There is unfinished business there.

clottey will lose again if he can't increase his punch output

[MurderDeathKill]

Josh has a better chance than Cotto in this fight. Clottey's got a better chin and defense than Miguel. He's naturally bigger and more durable.

Clottey is an average sized man, about 5'9'', probably walks around about 180-190lbs in decent shape. But when he entered the ring at 170lbs for a Welterweight fight, ripped and in tremendous shape, he's considered huge for the division. Manny is a small man, about 5'6'', and struggling to weigh as much as a Welterweight.

So yes, Clottey has a very good chance at beating the Pacman. Pac's gonna have to be extraordinary this Saturday, luckily for him, he's an extraordinary fighter.

Well anyway, so what if Clottey does beat Manny? I'd like to see a Clottey - Cotto rematch, it's a natural fit. And Manny to move back to 140lbs. There is so much talent at Jr Lightweight and I think Manny could clean out the division.

If Clottey wins, Pac may demand a rematch. Arum has another all Top Rank fight, so he'd want it. If not, then Clottey targets the Shane-Floyd winner. If Shane wins and it goes to a rematch with Floyd per the clause, then Clottey can fight Berto-Quintana winner or move to 154.

No point to a Cotto rematch. Cotto is finished. If Pac was dominated and/or KO'd by Clottey, then yes he should go back to 140 and defend the Ring bet vs Bradley.