Wazaa's Light Welterweight Ranking
Collapse
-
-
Comment
-
I've seen all types of post comparing them. The price moved like a ghost in the ring, Amir Khan kind of plods around like a Mexican fighter. Nazeem had so much rhythm I swear he was a professional dancer. I have the utmost respect for Price Naz. Khan gets no respect from me until he fights Devon or Timothy.Comment
-
Paulie has a better resume then Urango. Paulie has been in the top 10 JWW for a much longer time then Urango. The Ring magazine and BoxRec rates him higher and I just feel like Malignaggi is the more experienced and better fighter.
Amirs and Alexanders resume are comparible.
1. Alexander beat a past prime Witter. Still a good win. But not as impressive as Bradleys win who beat prime Witter in Witters own backyard. On top of that you also have to consider the fact that Witter had his longest lay-off in his pro career before fighting Alexander.
2. Alexander beat Urango. Who is a very good but also a bvery one-dimensional fighter. Yes, Alexander outboxed him beautifully but so did Hatton
. In fact, Urango was closing the distance between him and Alexander and later in the fight even starting to get his timing right. Still a very good win for Alexander. His best win IMO.
VS
1. Amir beat a prime Kotelnik. Kotelnik lost a very close fight against a prime Witter. In fact, some observers even gave Kotelnik the fight.
2. Amir stopped Malignaggi in his hometown at his own game. the game of standing in the middle of the ring. Just like Urango,Malignaggi had never been stopped before either [Not counting the bull**** stoppage against Hatton]. This was the real Malignaggi not the McGirt one. When Referee Smoger stopped this fight Malignaggi didn't complain at all.
You can have Alexander at #2. I can understand that but you should not complain about me having Amir at #2. The difference isnt significant enough to have a fuss about it.Comment
-
Beating Bailey>Beating Diaz.
Is not about who been where longer. It is about who the recently better resume. And, Urango does.Comment
-
I disagree. Who did Bailey beat
. Was Bailey past his prime? Possibly, considering his age. Didnt Bailey lose to Ngoudjou who 'The Real' Paulie dominated?
Comment
-
Who did Juan Diaz beat at 140? Is Diaz even a JWW? Lost to Ngoudjo but arguably deserved the decision. Also was coming off a win against Gato Figueroa. Again who did Diaz beat at 140? Malignaggi? That says more about Malignaggi then anyhing.
How can you rank Juan Diaz> Randall Baliey?
And, also Urango did better against Ngoudjo then Malignaggi did.Comment
-
there i fixed it 4 uComment
-
you're top 5 is acceptable the order is all ****ed up can you go ahead and correct it please.
thanks
C+Comment

Comment