Where would Floyd rank with the ATG WW's if he beat Mosley and Pac?

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

I dont have him ranked at WW at all. Would wins over Mosley and Pac give him the edge to get in a list at WW.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Not near the top 25

[keepthemhandsup]

not that much....then again i rate his lower weightclass better then his WW

[El Jesus]

is there really a point to asking these questions while someones career is still going? i mean lets be real, who in the **** sits there with their top lists and then periodically adjusts and reranks them based on recent events? ****ing nobody, especially when talking ATGs. Most people on this site, including myself, have a tough time remember who did what when and where especially in a historically great division like welter, let alone what a guy with less than 10 fights at that weight would rank in that particular division

[ModernTalking]

Floyd is not ranking anywhere. His chance at ATG welter was to fight Margarito and than an undefeated Cotto.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Not near the top 25

Thats what I was thinking Top 25-30 at WW. He was a Lineal Champ, Undefeated at that weight, and fought Judah the Number 2 guy, Baldi the number 1, Shane is the Number 2 guy, and Pac is the Number one guy. Shane and Pac also the 1 and 3 best in the world at any weight. I think he would have a good case for 25-30 range.

#1 guy
#2 guy
#2 guy
#1 guy

[keepthemhandsup]

is there really a point to asking these questions while someones career is still going? i mean lets be real, who in the **** sits there with their top lists and then periodically adjusts and reranks them based on recent events? ****ing nobody, especially when talking ATGs. Most people on this site, including myself, have a tough time remember who did what when and where especially in a historically great division like welter, let alone what a guy with less than 10 fights at that weight would rank in that particular division

what he said is how i also feel on this matter

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

is there really a point to asking these questions while someones career is still going? i mean lets be real, who in the **** sits there with their top lists and then periodically adjusts and reranks them based on recent events? ****ing nobody, especially when talking ATGs. Most people on this site, including myself, have a tough time remember who did what when and where especially in a historically great division like welter, let alone what a guy with less than 10 fights at that weight would rank in that particular division

Its a valid discussion. It beats Floyd vs. Pac talk. Hes already an ATG Super Feather Weight, WW would be his next best class to make a case for. No one asked for an exact ranking just a range. I think some guys can rattle off some top ATG WW's not everyone though.

[SonOfCuba]

he will get ranked very high if he beats those two, no doubt about it.

[EL_cano]

I will rank top 50 after Mayweather retires.