Top 15 P4P!

[!! Mr. Soprano]

Plus Wright needs to fight a shot Vargas and avange one of his losses!

[NiGe2011]

Winky won that fight in my opinion- and apparently his opinion too since he is now refusing to fight El Feroz again now that Vargas is down and out and he is finally up on top. He says Winky refused to give him a rematch after what was essentially a gift decision and so he is not going to give Vargas a fight. Winky's last three wins are Mosley, Mosley, and Tito- that is a pretty good list. There are few on the list who boast three wins over equal quality opponents in their last three bouts, only Corrales, Morales, and maybe another fighter or two... But that's it.

[!! Mr. Soprano]

Winky won that fight in my opinion- and apparently his opinion too since he is now refusing to fight El Feroz again now that Vargas is down and out and he is finally up on top. He says Winky refused to give him a rematch after what was essentially a gift decision and so he is not going to give Vargas a fight. Winky's last three wins are Mosley, Mosley, and Tito- that is a pretty good list. There are few on the list who boast three wins over equal quality opponents in their last three bouts, only Corrales, Morales, and maybe another fighter or two... But that's it.

My point exactly "Winky's last three wins are Mosley, Mosley, and Tito- that is a pretty good list." No it's not.. not good enough to be P4P #2.

Tszyu has wis over:
Sharmba Mitchell x2 - TKO
Jesse James Leija - TKO
Zab Judah - TKO
Julio Cesar Chavez - TKO
Oktay Urkal
etc...

Mayweather:
DeMarcus Corley
Jose Luis Castillo x2
Diego Corrales - TKO
etc..

No way does "Winky's last three wins are Mosley, Mosley, and Tito" put him above.. Tszyu is by far more dominant in his division.

My list
#1 - Hopkins
#2 - Tszyu
#3 - Mayweather
#4 - Morales
and maybe Wright as #5, or even 6 if Barrera as #5

[NiGe2011]

Kostya has one fight in two years. On the Mayweather list the only recent one is Corley. Mosley was a Top Ten P4P guy when Winky beat him (the first time). And he moved up in weight to dominate the heavy fisted Tito. I think P4P is more about, what have you done for me lately. And lately Winky has done some of the most in boxing.

[!! Mr. Soprano]

Kostya has one fight in two years. On the Mayweather list the only recent one is Corley. Mosley was a Top Ten P4P guy when Winky beat him (the first time). And he moved up in weight to dominate the heavy fisted Tito. I think P4P is more about, what have you done for me lately. And lately Winky has done some of the most in boxing.

This is where you and I disagree. For me it's not what you have done lately, but what have you done throughout your career.

Hopkins unbeaten for 10+ years.. that's huge!

Tszyu has destroyed and dominated every fighter, but Hatton and Mayweather, in his division.. soon it will be down to only Mayweather...



Not just last 2-3 good fights..

[TheGreat1]

My point exactly "Winky's last three wins are Mosley, Mosley, and Tito- that is a pretty good list." No it's not.. not good enough to be P4P #2.

Tszyu has wis over:
Sharmba Mitchell x2 - TKO
Jesse James Leija - TKO
Zab Judah - TKO
Julio Cesar Chavez - TKO
Oktay Urkal
etc...

Mayweather:
DeMarcus Corley
Jose Luis Castillo x2
Diego Corrales - TKO
etc..

No way does "Winky's last three wins are Mosley, Mosley, and Tito" put him above.. Tszyu is by far more dominant in his division.

My list
#1 - Hopkins
#2 - Tszyu
#3 - Mayweather
#4 - Morales
and maybe Wright as #5, or even 6 if Barrera as #5

I have to disagree about winky. Beating SSM and Tito says alot these are two of the best fighters of our time. True they have been outboxed in a few fights, but these two are both better than
Shamba,a very old and past his prime JCC, Leija, and Urkal. Don't get me wrong Tszyu is a great fighter, and i can see how you can put him above Wright, but i disagree that his comp was better than wrights. SSM and Tito are greaters, they where just exposed by a great boxer.