Who has a better case of winning?

[Swag Hustla]

I saw a thread similar this, but with different fights/fighters.

Who has a better case of winning:

Jose Luis Castillo over Mayweather I or

Marquez over Pacquiao I and/or II

[The_Demon]

castillo clearly beat mayweather first time round imo

both pac/marquez fights could have gone either way

[Dirt McGirt]

castillo clearly beat mayweather first time round imo

both pac/marquez fights could have gone either way

I second that.

It's easily Castillo, I think even Mayweather fans would agree to that.

[Crash Bandicoot]

It's JMM - Pac without doubt

Most boxing experts had Marquez winning over Pacquiao:

- Associated Press:114-113 Marquez
- Joe Santoliquito:115-112 Marquez
- Dan Rafael, ESPN.com: 114-113 Marquez
- Darius Ortiz, ESPN.com:114-113 Marquez
- Eric Raskin, ESPN.com:114-113 Marquez
- Brian Kenny, Friday Night Fights:115-112 Marquez
- Scott Mallon, Ring Magazine / Boxing News / The Fist / Boxing Digest:114-113 Marquez
- Yahoo Sports:115-112 Marquez
- Fight News.com:115-112 Marquez
- Steve Carp, Las Vegas Review Journal: 114-113 Marquez
- Norm Fraunheim, Arizona Republic:114-113 Marquez
- Rich Marrotta, Top Rank TV:114-113 Marquez
- Kieran Mulvaney, Reuters:114-113 Marquez
- DogHouseBoxing:114-113 Marquez
- Brett Conway, MaxBoxing.com:114-113 Marquez
- Rick Reeno, BoxingScene.com:114-113 Marquez
- Gary Randall, MaxBoxing.com:114-113 Marquez
- Bart Barry, 15Rounds.com:115-113 Marquez
- Bruce McTavish, International Judge:115-112 Marquez
- Francis Ochoa, Philippine Daily Inquirer:114-113 Marquez
- Scott Christ, BadLeftHook.com:114-113 Marquez
- William Detloff, The Ring Magazine:115-113 Marquez
- Ron Borges, TheSweetScience.com:114-113 Marquez
- Bert Sugar:Marquez
- Max Kellerman & Bob Papa:Marquez in both fights
- Nonito Donaire:114-113 Marquez
- Filipino Sports Analysts Ronnie Nathanielsz, Recah Trinidad and Ed Picson all picked Marquez.
- Graham Houston, FightWriter.com also picked Marquez


Pacquiao wins the vacant Ring Magazine jr. lightweight world title. Ring Magazine awarded the belt to Pacquiao but did not believe he won the fight

[Swag Hustla]

I second that.

It's easily Castillo, I think even Mayweather fans would agree to that.

Just based on the reaction from the HBO commentators. And Floyd is one of HBO's "chosen ones".

The Pacquiao and Marquez fights were razor-thin decisions that could have gone either way. If Marquez won, an equal amount of people would have said Pacquiao should have won it.

In fights that close, it almost seems better to lose. The fans will sympathize and it makes the other guy look like the thief who stole your win, lol.

[Xyei]

Unfortunately, this is simply going to turn into a war between the *******s and *****s.

[UnDeniable]

Probably Castillo but Floyd beat Castillo clearly the 2nd time

Pacquiao couldn't get it done clearly in two tries

In the words of Jigga "Flame on"

[UnDeniable]

Unfortunately, this is simply going to turn into a war between the *******s and *****s.

I'm guessing 7 pages