Lets be honest, anyone can pick flaws in any fighters wins.
A few of Floyds best wins:
Corrales: Weight drained, not at his strongest at the weight
Castillo: Could argue he lost the 1st fight
Baldomir: Limited fighter
De La Hoya: Old and past it
Hatton: Ineffective at 147
Marquez: Very ineffective at 147, never fought any higher than 135 previously
A few of Pac's biggest wins:
Morales: Past it, coming off a loss to Rahim
Marquez: Could argue he lost either if not both fights
De La Hoys: Old, past it and weight drained
Hatton: Shot and over rated
Cotto: Shot and scarred after Margarito
When in reality the vast majority of these wins, while not perfect are still exceptional
Flogically speaking those guys were all ATG fighters, but Judah has to be the greatest foe he faced.
They were not ATG's but neither were supposed guys he ducked, Margarito, Cotto and Clottey. The guys you mentioned are closer to ATG status than those 3.
40 have tried.
40 came up short.
1 will come up short again May 1st.
The other one will come up short too once the fight happens.
Comment