Rate These 5 fighters in order of Greatness??

[baracuda]

at 118 he showed brilliance, but not 6 years.. like I said he deserves the top vote.. but he's not leagues above Taylor and the others..

its all opinion my brother, i dont see anyone better than rafa in his days or now......thats how good i think was and i think he aint done yet.....

[DiLLiNGER]

Juan Diaz
Paul Malignaggi
Jermain Taylor
Rafael Marquez
Zab Judah

Zab Judah
Jermain Taylor
Paul Malignaggi
Rafael Marquez

[baracuda]

Zab Judah
Jermain Taylor
Paul Malignaggi
Rafael Marquez

you mean raul marquez not rafael...

[JM1]

Juan Diaz
Paul Malignaggi
Jermain Taylor
Rafael Marquez
Zab Judah

marquez
taylor
diaz
judah
malignaggi

[Heru]

R. Marquez
Taylor
Judah
Diaz
Maliggnaggi

Rafa should be everyone's #1

[badboypeenoy]

Taylor went as high as P4P #5
Marquez was P4P #7 or #8
Malignaggi champ, beaten by P4P listers and a controversial loss to Diaz
Juan Diaz multiple belts in his prime got beat by an old soupy and Malignaggi
Judah multiple belts but was beaten in his prime by a journeyman

[steeluv]

The only one who was great was taylor at one time. The others aint shown greatnessssssssssssss


i think most ppl are overating j diaz who was in weak division and he lost a close fight to old man campbell and marquez at that weight he was supposed to be great at.. Like to see how many rounds he could last against valero at lw

[DiLLiNGER]

you mean raul marquez not rafael...

the TS put down rafael.

[KJB]

nah that would be hasegawa

Facepalm.
No, Marquez was the man at 118. More dominant than Hasegawa. He is definitely at the top of the list.
I would also have Jermain in the two spot because he took the title from a Champion, not a guy wearing some ***elry.

[The Surgeon]

Marquez
Taylor
Judah
Diaz/Malinaggi