If they had a super six Light welter, who would you have in it?

[#1Assassin]

theres too many good boxers in this division they should have a super 10

1.Edwin Valero
2.Timothy Bradley
3.Amir Khan
4.Victor Ortiz
5.marcos maidana
6.Paulie Malignaggi
7.Juan Urango
8.Devon Alexander
9.Nate Campbell
10.Ricky Hatton


Theres also over a dozen undefeated dudes, nobody ever heard of.

Bradley
Khan
JMM
Urango/Alexander winner

Pacquiao moves down, and valero moves up to join the comp

If it were an 8 man tourney: addin Hatton and Maidana.

oh this is such bull****.

casamayor has a way stronger legacy than anybody else at 140, including hatton.

his last loss was to juan manuel ****ing marquez, and it was very competetive to say the least. u could very well have had him up on points when it was stopped.

u ppl put guys like maidana, ortiz and valero over casamayor?

and nobody other than myself even mentioned el cepillo yet.. ****ing bull****..

[SpinDoctor]

casamayor has a way stronger legacy than anybody else at 140, including hatton.
.

?????????????????????????????????? you on crack dude? casamayor has fought 1 fight in his entire career at 140 and he is 38 years old.

[wazaa.]

mine would look like this you guys:

1. Timothy Bradley
2. Amir Khan
3. Devon Alexander
4. Paulie Malignaggi
5. Marcos Maidana
6. Victor Ortiz

[Squirrel]

oh this is such bull****.

casamayor has a way stronger legacy than anybody else at 140, including hatton.

his last loss was to juan manuel ****ing marquez, and it was very competetive to say the least. u could very well have had him up on points when it was stopped.

u ppl put guys like maidana, ortiz and valero over casamayor?

and nobody other than myself even mentioned el cepillo yet.. ****ing bull****..

Whoah man, settle down like, it's a fantasy thread.

I like Bradley and would like to see him up against these guys - i'd love him to step up and get his resume on the go. Same goes for Valero, and i was kinda joking ...

Khan has fast hands but a pathetic chin, so you can guarantee a good fight (to be fair i hate the guy so would like to see him in with some better opponents than we've seen him in there with).

JMM is a favorite of mine and stylistically I think he'd make some great fights.

Urango/alexander winner out of curiosity as i haven't seen a great deal of these two, but it'd be cool to get another couple of belts in the mix.

Hatton i'd be interested in to see what else he can do at this stage.

Maidana is a wildcard, he's fun to watch and he'd make for some good fights with any of the others, win or lose.

finally, Pacman was kinda a joke ..

[#1Assassin]

?????????????????????????????????? you on crack dude? casamayor has fought 1 fight in his entire career at 140 and he is 38 years old.

valero hasnt even fought at 140 once and ppl are including him.

who cares how old he is? hes still amongst the best fighters in the division, his credentials speak for themselfs.

how many fighters can u make a case would beat casamyor at 140? bradley, maybe campbell (who casa already beat) and thats it. guys like khan, maidana and alexander hasnt fought anybody that would make u pick them over casamayor.

[Albo Dakkid]

1.Bradley
2.Khan
3.Alexander
4.Maidana(you need a dangerous puncher there to mix things up)
5.Marquez
6.Judah

[#1Assassin]

Whoah man, settle down like, it's a fantasy thread.

I like Bradley and would like to see him up against these guys - i'd love him to step up and get his resume on the go. Same goes for Valero, and i was kinda joking ...

Khan has fast hands but a pathetic chin, so you can guarantee a good fight (to be fair i hate the guy so would like to see him in with some better opponents than we've seen him in there with).

JMM is a favorite of mine and stylistically I think he'd make some great fights.

Urango/alexander winner out of curiosity as i haven't seen a great deal of these two, but it'd be cool to get another couple of belts in the mix.

Hatton i'd be interested in to see what else he can do at this stage.

Maidana is a wildcard, he's fun to watch and he'd make for some good fights with any of the others, win or lose.

finally, Pacman was kinda a joke ..

i am settled down. not including casamayor is ****ing bull**** so i wrote its ****ing bull****.. but its not like im gettin all upset about it.

casamyor just deserves to be in there, theres no excuse u can make..

hes only fought at 140 once.. valero never fought at 140 at all.
hes past his prime.. hatton.. enough said.
he lost his last big fight.. hatton.. enough said
hes old.. campbell..

truth is casamyor has more credentials than anyone at 140, and should be a favourite over anyone at the weight except for bradley and maybe campbell (who casa beat once).

[S.G.]

- Timothy Bradley
- Amir Khan/Juan Manuel Marquez winner
- Devon Alexander/Juan Urango winner
- Victor Ortiz/Nate Campbell winner
- Kendall Holt
- Marcos Maidana

[Squirrel]

i am settled down. not including casamayor is ****ing bull**** so i wrote its ****ing bull****.. but its not like im gettin all upset about it.

casamyor just deserves to be in there, theres no excuse u can make..

hes only fought at 140 once.. valero never fought at 140 at all.
hes past his prime.. hatton.. enough said.
he lost his last big fight.. hatton.. enough said
hes old.. campbell..

truth is casamyor has more credentials than anyone at 140, and should be a favourite over anyone at the weight except for bradley and maybe campbell (who casa beat once).

You don't seem very settled to me, usually when I see people dropping the F-bomb and claiming things are bull**** they're at least a little heated, and it's quite evident you are haha.

Here's my excuse for not putting him in: it's a fantasy thread based on opinions.

I can put whoever i want in my list,you don't need to get all pissy cause people don't agree with your opinion, however well you back it up.

[revs1227]

1bradley
2paulie
3maidana
4holt
5ortiz
6valero

bradley wins or maybe paulie