Which fight was Closer? Oscar-Floyd or Mosley-Cotto?

[bdevils]

FACTS


Mosley vs Cotto: 116-113, 115-113 twice, all in favor of Miguel (UD)

Oscar vs Floyd: 115-113 for DLH; 116-112 & 115-113 for Duck (SD)

Try watching the fights instead of just looking at a scorecard. Btw, your thread failed loser!

[Sweet Jesus]

FACTS


Mosley vs Cotto: 116-113, 115-113 twice, all in favor of Miguel (UD)

Oscar vs Floyd: 115-113 for DLH; 116-112 & 115-113 for Duck (SD)

In that case, did you really you need to make a thread about it?

[DiegoFuego]

Oscar-Floyd wasn't close at all. That was a 9-3, 8-4 type fight if you're generous to De La Hoya. Mosley-Cotto was 115-113 and hard to say it was any wider than that for Cotto.

[2120]

FACTS


Mosley vs Cotto: 116-113, 115-113 twice, all in favor of Miguel (UD)

Oscar vs Floyd: 115-113 for DLH; 116-112 & 115-113 for Duck (SD)

Officals dont always get it right every time

in my opinion they did not get it right when floyd first fought castillo or when sweet pea fought chavez

and all these people believe the officials did not get the Marquez vs pac II fight right either

- Associated Press:114-113 Marquez
- Joe Santoliquito:115-112 Marquez
- Dan Rafael, ESPN.com: 114-113 Marquez
- Darius Ortiz, ESPN.com:114-113 Marquez
- Eric Raskin, ESPN.com:114-113 Marquez
- Brian Kenny, Friday Night Fights:115-112 Marquez
- Scott Mallon, Ring Magazine / Boxing News / The Fist / Boxing Digest:114-113 Marquez
- Yahoo Sports:115-112 Marquez
- Fight News.com:115-112 Marquez
- Steve Carp, Las Vegas Review Journal: 114-113 Marquez
- Norm Fraunheim, Arizona Republic:114-113 Marquez
- Rich Marrotta, Top Rank TV:114-113 Marquez
- Kieran Mulvaney, Reuters:114-113 Marquez
- DogHouseBoxing:114-113 Marquez
- Brett Conway, MaxBoxing.com:114-113 Marquez
- Rick Reeno, BoxingScene.com:114-113 Marquez
- Gary Randall, MaxBoxing.com:114-113 Marquez
- Bart Barry, 15Rounds.com:115-113 Marquez
- Bruce McTavish, International Judge:115-112 Marquez
- Francis Ochoa, Philippine Daily Inquirer:114-113 Marquez
- Scott Christ, BadLeftHook.com:114-113 Marquez
- William Detloff, The Ring Magazine:115-113 Marquez
- Ron Borges, TheSweetScience.com:114-113 Marquez
- Bert Sugar:Marquez
- Max Kellerman & Bob Papa:Marquez in both fights
- Nonito Donaire:114-113 Marquez
- Filipino Sports Analysts Ronnie Nathanielsz, Recah Trinidad and Ed Picson all picked Marquez.


if you watch both cotto vs shane and oscar vs floyd and you know how to score a fight then its obvious that

the cotto vs shane fight was closer and competitive while floyd uneventful fight with oscar was not close at all.

[Stuey's Revenge]

Cotto-Mosley was closer. Cotto faded late which made it closer. I scored Floyd/Oscar 8-4. Through 8 rounds I had it 4-4. Then DLH does what he always does,fade late in fights,which allowed lil floyd to take control.

[DiegoFuego]

FACTS


Mosley vs Cotto: 116-113, 115-113 twice, all in favor of Miguel (UD)

Oscar vs Floyd: 115-113 for DLH; 116-112 & 115-113 for Duck (SD)

your thread failed, get over it. Nobody thinks De La Hoya-Mayweather was close, and if they do, they didn't care to explain it in the thread.

[bdevils]

Wonder why it's only Pac cheerleaders that voted Oscar-Floyd?

[JoeyNumbers]

The fact that Oscar and Mosley lost and wanted rematches show neither were clearly defeated. For a UD win you should beat your opponent so bad, that he wouldn't even think of asking for a rematch. You opponent should know he was beat... and know he has no chance.

At the end of both those fights...I had no idea who won. And after they announced the winners... I was hoping both Cotto and Mayweather would have the integrity to show they could do better.

[Thread Stealer]

I had Cotto-Mosley 115-113 for Cotto and Mayweather-De La Hoya 116-112 for Mayweather.

[bdevils]

The fact that Oscar and Mosley lost and wanted rematches show neither were clearly defeated. For a UD win you should beat your opponent so bad, that he wouldn't even think of asking for a rematch. You opponent should know he was beat... and know he has no chance.

At the end of both those fights...I had no idea who won. And after they announced the winners... I was hoping both Cotto and Mayweather would have the integrity to show they could do better.

If you didn't know who should of won the Floyd-Oscar fight before they announced it, maybe it's time to watch a different sport.