So Let's Say Shane Wins.....

**TITO SEVERE** · 01-31-2010, 10:42 PM

Originally posted by Makavelli

...would you guys have any problems putting him at #2 on your p4p list?

please vote

I think he belongs at # 1 on the list of WW's right now. It pains me to see Manny and Floyd ranked above him when Manny only has one W at 147 over Oscar and Floyd hasn't beat a WW since Bush was Prez. Honestly Mosey to me should and will beat Mayfeather on May 1st. After that I hope he meets Pacquiao and we can watch those punches bounce off his chin and see him take that W so people on here can eat their words.

**Sutekh uvdabrix** · 01-31-2010, 10:43 PM

I want to see shane KO the hell out of manny..

**illmatickid** · 01-31-2010, 10:44 PM

i have no problem putting him there as long as its not a bull**** decision and that he clearly won... he deserves it

if floyd gets robbed he should still be #2 pound for pound

**krispy kreme** · 01-31-2010, 10:44 PM

A win over Mayweather is huge, the best win possible I think. I would be hard pressed to say number 1.

**-MAKAVELLI-** · 01-31-2010, 10:47 PM

Originally posted by TITO SEVERE

I think he belongs at # 1 on the list of WW's right now. It pains me to see Manny and Floyd ranked above him when Manny only has one W at 147 over Oscar and Floyd hasn't beat a WW since Bush was Prez. Honestly Mosey to me should and will beat Mayfeather on May 1st. After that I hope he meets Pacquiao and we can watch those punches bounce off his chin and see him take that W so people on here can eat their words.

p4p list bro...not WW rankings...welcome to boxingscene

Originally posted by Jewshua Loc

A win over Mayweather is huge, the best win possible I think. I would be hard pressed to say number 1.

DAMN...all the way to # 1? interesting

**krispy kreme** · 01-31-2010, 10:48 PM

Originally posted by Makavelli

p4p list bro...not WW rankings...welcome to boxingscene

DAMN...all the way to # 1? interesting

Maybe I am overrating a win over Mayweather, but that is as significant a win as you could get. IDK though.

**illmatickid** · 01-31-2010, 10:48 PM

Originally posted by Jewshua Loc

A win over Mayweather is huge, the best win possible I think. I would be hard pressed to say number 1.

i was gonna say that too.. i wouldnt hesitate putting him there either

**War Dinamita** · 01-31-2010, 10:49 PM

Yes, definitely at #2 if the beats the best boxer in the world without weight draining like someone we know.

**-MAKAVELLI-** · 01-31-2010, 10:51 PM

Originally posted by Jewshua Loc

Maybe I am overrating a win over Mayweather, but that is as significant a win as you could get. IDK though.

it would have to be a superb performance for me to even think about putting him at the # 1 spot TBH....a dominating, PAC-Cotto type beatdown

So Let's Say Shane Wins.....