Better Resume: Quintana or Clottey?

[catalinul]

Resume:Clottey

Resume of wins:Quintana

[Junito-Rulez]

Clottey has faced the better opposition with Cotto and Margarito, but never won a big fight.
Quintana beat the better opposition with Paul Williams, Julio. Quintana has the better resume, if you mean who has the better wins.

[Liar]

Carlos Q has a better resume. Clottey is the only boxer who gets credit losing

[BoxerDood]

Its hard to say. If Quintana hadn't gotten stopped in 5 rounds by Cotto then I would have easily said him...

I wish the Clottey-Quintana fight would have happened...it would have been pretty even.

[MOTHER DUCKER]

They both b class fighters at best