Who has fought the better opposition? Mosley or Mayweather?

[Jim Jeffries]

Anyone that picks Floyd probably thinks him and Shane fought the same version of DLH, as well.

[DonTaseMeBrah]

so its pretty clear cut that shane has fought the better opposition. So who has the better resume? Who ranks higher all time great?

If i did the poll on that question, it might go the opposite way.

If shane has clearly fought the much much better opposition why is it that mayweather is held at such high regard?

[Mr. Philadel]

so its pretty clear cut that shane has fought the better opposition. So who has the better resume? Who ranks higher all time great?

If i did the poll on that question, it might go the opposite way.

If shane has clearly fought the much much better opposition why is it that mayweather is held at such high regard?

its the 0 I guess...

[Pugilistic™]

Mosley - Oscar, Cotto, Forrest, Wright, Margarito, Mayorga, Vargas, Collazo. You could probably add a few more lesser known names in there.

Mayweather - Oscar, Hatton, Castillo, Corrales, Marquez, Gatti, Judah. Theres probably a few lesser known names i could fit in there also.

It's clearly Mosley.

[DonTaseMeBrah]

Let's see shane's degree of difficulty;

fernando vargas 2x at 154
winky wright prime 2x at 154
vernon forrest prime 2x at 147
miguel cotto prime at 147
luis collazo prime at 147
oscar de la hoya prime 2x at 147 & at 154
margarito at 147

Does Fraud jr. go undefeated taking on the above fighters?

[damned1974]

Who has fought the better opposition? Choogar Chane Mosley or the Fraudulent One Fraud Mayweather jr.?


poll & explain.

This thread may later show irony.I believe obviously that Shane Mosely has been in against the best.If Floyd faces him and beats him,(since a lot of people believe Floyd is fighting someone who is a huge step up in competition) then which excuses will be made? Keep in mind that Shane did what a prime Cotto couldn't-he ko'd the iron chinned Margarito.

[Ekscape]

Mosley has fought better competition then everyone in the whole Welterweight division...

Oscar x2
Wink Wright x2
Vernon Forest x2
Miguel Cotto
Fernando Vargas
Ricardo Mayorga
Antonio Margarito
Luis Callazo


If someone can go through those 11 fights undefeated then they're top 10 P4P all time

[DonTaseMeBrah]

its the 0 I guess...

undefeated records = su****ousness;

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=352174

This thread may later show irony.I believe obviously that Shane Mosely has been in against the best.If Floyd faces him and beats him,(since a lot of people believe Floyd is fighting someone who is a huge step up in competition) then which excuses will be made? Keep in mind that Shane did what a prime Cotto couldn't-he ko'd the iron chinned Margarito.

Shane is 38 years old going on 39 in 4 months when that fight happens, he will be out of the ring in about 16 months since he last fought. there is that.

Mosley has fought better competition then everyone in the whole Welterweight division...

Oscar x2
Wink Wright x2
Vernon Forest x2
Miguel Cotto
Fernando Vargas
Ricardo Mayorga
Antonio Margarito
Luis Callazo


If someone can go through those 11 fights undefeated then they're top 10 P4P all time

settle down brah.

[BritishBoxing92]

Who has fought the better opposition? Choogar Chane Mosley or the Fraudulent One Fraud Mayweather jr.?


poll & explain.

Mosely Beat Marg and also fighted cotto...2 guys who people say floyd supposebly ducked

[-Reflexes-]

I meant to vote Mosley. I thought the TS meant who has the better resume. Thats Floyd clearly.