Joshua Clottey vs Luis Collazo: Who Wins?

[ny123]

Collazo got outmuscled and walked down by Ricky Hatton, enough said.

no he didnt rewatch that fight it was a close fight that collazo should have won but i do agree with you that clottey would be just a little too much for collazo

[mangler jr]

Its hard to say since both are low work rate counterpunchers.

If I had to pick I'd go w/ a Collazo decision based on slightly quicker hands and better footwork.

Boring fight imo.

[jrosales13]

I was unaware that Clottey has won a major fight. Can you please provide the details for me?

Corrales and Judah? Those were televised by HBO and Showtime and they were main event... Not great win but those were Clottey major fights... IMO Collazo has not had a victory like those yet... Plus you can add Clottey wins over prospects like Alvarez and Gutierrez... I also don't think Collazo has wins that are as good as those...

[Easy-E]

Pacquiao
Mayweather
-----------
Cotto
Mosley
Clottey
Margario
-----------
Collazo
Berto
Quintana
Judah


Those are the different classes of fighters in the welterweight division.

I think Clottey is in that third group. E****ially because he lost to two of the fighters in his supposed group.

[Easy-E]

Corrales and Judah? Those were televised by HBO and Showtime and they were main event... Not great win but those were Clottey major fights... IMO Collazo has not had a victory like those yet... Plus you can add Clottey wins over prospects like Alvarez and Gutierrez... I also don't think Collazo has wins that are as good as those...

Come on, these fights had little impact. Both guys were completly finished with sub par chins and Clottey could not finish either of them. I would not conisder them major fights.

[mangler jr]

Corrales and Judah? Those were televised by HBO and Showtime and they were main event... Not great win but those were Clottey major fights... IMO Collazo has not had a victory like those yet... Plus you can add Clottey wins over prospects like Alvarez and Gutierrez... I also don't think Collazo has wins that are as good as those...

The Judah win was decent win. Shamone Alvarez is a decent win, but nothing spectacular. And I give him no credit for beating Corrales.

Diego was way out of his league at WW and was coming off the Castillo trilogy.

After the second fight both he and Jose were finished as world class fighters.

[ny123]

Come on, these fights had little impact. Both guys were completly finished with sub par chins and Clottey could not finish either of them. I would not conisder them major fights.

both were solid fighters who clottey clearly beat and judah gave a game effort he didnt show up just to get a check not to mention that clottey has clearly fought the better comp of the two cotto and margs are both better then anyone collazo has been in the ring with

[jrosales13]

Come on, these fights had little impact. Both guys were completly finished with sub par chins and Clottey could not finish either of them. I would not conisder them major fights.

But, does Collazo has any win that can top that? If so please name?

[GTL]

WOW.. its really funny that you made this thread.. I was going to post this up. Its a good change from the usual Pac, MMay **** we deal with..

This is a pick em fight.. collazo has really good movement, and josh is more powerful.. I like them both too.. Both NY fighters!

I think Collazo by SD because clottey doesnt let his hands go enough..

[clemente]

collazo would take this, dont think clottey could handle the southpaw